Abstract
Access to a physician is uneven. In a 2025 survey of physician offices in 15 large US metro areas, the average wait for a new-patient appointment across six specialties was 31 days1. In the studies this paper cites, 18.8% to 23% of booked visits are missed2,3.
So a practice can be short of appointments and still lose patients and visits it could have kept. Marketing for such a practice is access: being found by the patients it wants, being reached when they call, and keeping the visits that are booked, with tools that stay inside HIPAA. This paper sets out the evidence on how patients choose a physician, how a practice is found in search and in AI answers, what the Privacy Rule and the regulators say about marketing, tracking and reviews, and what a marketing plan, an answering agent and a compliance program each have to bring in to cover their cost. Our study of AI answers did not ask about physicians, and the paper says so wherever the study is used.
Six chapters cover access and choice, medical SEO and AI answers, healthcare advertising under HIPAA, the answering service and the AI receptionist, where AI pays in a medical practice, and measurement with a first 90 days. The paper calls no tool HIPAA compliant. It is not medical or legal advice, and a practice's counsel or privacy officer decides how any rule applies.
What this paper argues
- Access is uneven, so marketing is the work of being found, being reached and keeping the visits that are booked: new-patient waits averaged 31 days in one survey of 15 metros1, and 18.8% to 23% of booked visits are missed in the studies cited2,3.
- In a 2012 survey of the US public, 89% rated whether a physician accepted their health insurance very important when choosing a primary care doctor, and 19% rated physician ratings on websites very important4.
- The Privacy Rule requires an authorization for any use or disclosure of protected health information for marketing, with two stated exceptions5, and a federal court has declared a portion of HHS's guidance on online tracking tools unlawful and vacated it6.
- No standard in the Security Rule requires a covered entity to certify its compliance7, so the question to put to any tool is whether its vendor will sign a business associate agreement and how the tool is set up.
- On cited figures, a marketing plan at $999 a month8 is covered by 3.3 new primary care patients a month counted over their first year, computed from federal survey payments per visit9. An answering agent is $299 a month with 250 call minutes included8, the cost of about 8.6 front-desk hours. The HIPAA-ready program it runs inside is a separate layer that every tool handling patient information shares10; with reminders running on it, about 5.2 kept visits a month cover it. The system loses money only where a practice is not growing and its intake and scheduling are already sufficiently optimized.
How to read this paper
- ~
- Our estimate, built from the nearest cited figures. Not a measurement.
- †
- A vendor’s own figure, from its customers or its own survey. Not an independent sample.
- NF
- Not found: we looked for a published measure and found none.
- ( )
- A figure followed by its working in brackets, or by “calc.”, is our arithmetic on cited figures.
- Rules
- We report what each rule says as read on the date shown. This is not legal advice, and counsel decides how a rule applies to you.
- Sources
- A small number points to the source in References, which says where we hold a source only through its abstract or a secondary account.
Chapter 1
Medical practice marketing and patient access
In early 2025, AMN Healthcare's researchers called physician offices in 15 metro areas to schedule a new-patient appointment. The average wait they found, across six specialties, was 31 days1. In the studies we cite, 18.8% to 23% of booked visits are missed2,3, and callers do not always reach anyone. So a practice can be short of appointments and still lose patients and visits it could have kept. Marketing for such a practice is access: being found by the patients it wants, being reached when they call, and keeping the visits that are booked.
The wait for a new-patient appointment
The AMN Healthcare survey ran from January 15 to February 24, 2025, and covers 1,391 offices1. The 31-day average wait was up 19% since the survey was last conducted in 2022 and up 48% since it was first conducted in 20041. Table 1 gives specialty waits and payer acceptance.
| Measure in the 2025 survey | Result |
|---|---|
| Average new-patient wait, six specialties, 15 large metro areas | 31 days1 |
| Average wait to see a family medicine physician | 23.5 days, from 1 day to 207 days1 |
| Average wait to see a dermatologist | 36.5 days1 |
| Average wait to see a cardiologist | 32.7 days1 |
| Physician offices accepting Medicaid | 53%1 |
| Physician offices accepting Medicare | 82%1 |
Table 1. New-patient waits and payer acceptance in AMN Healthcare's 2025 survey of physician offices in 15 metro areas.
The spread matters more than the average. In family medicine the waits ranged from a low of 1 day to a high of 207 days1. The longest wait is nearly nine times the average (207 / 23.5, about 8.8) and more than six months. The average describes no single office, so a practice should measure its own wait and not rely on a published figure, as Chapter 6 describes.
The survey covers physician offices in 15 large metro areas, so it says nothing about small towns or rural areas. Its figure is a wait for a new-patient appointment, not for an established patient, and the comparisons with 2022 and 2004 are the survey's own1. It does not say why an office had the wait it had. A long wait can come from a full schedule, from limits a practice sets on new patients by payer, specialty or visit type, or from openings that missed visits leave unfilled, and an average cannot tell these apart. The 31 days is consistent with a full schedule in some offices; it is not proof of one in any particular office.
We think a wait of weeks and a loss of patients can sit in the same practice. A new patient sees the wait. The practice does not see the loss: the caller who reaches no one, the booked patient who does not come, the patient who is never recalled. Not every practice is in that position: the shortest family medicine wait in the AMN survey was 1 day1. Each practice knows which case it is in, and the paper is written for both: for a practice with a queue, marketing decides who is let in and what is kept, and for one with open slots, it fills them.
Medical practice marketing and the business: ownership, size and cost
Physician-owned practice is a shrinking share: in the Physician Practice Benchmark Survey of the American Medical Association (AMA), 60.1% of physicians were in private practice in 2012, 56.8% in 2014, 49.1% in 2020, 46.7% in 2022 and 42.2% in 202411. The AMA counts a practice as private when physicians wholly own it11. Only 35.4% of physicians had an ownership stake in their practice in 2024, against 53.2% in 201211; that is a different measure from the share in private practice, and the two should not be set against each other. In 2024, 6.5% of physicians characterized their practice as private equity-owned, higher than the around 4.5% of 2020 and 202211. And 47.4% worked in practices with 10 or fewer physicians in 2024, compared with 61.4% in 201211.
In 2024 the AMA switched its survey vendor from M3 Global Research to WebMD/Medscape and expanded the sample from 3,500 to 5,000 physicians11, so trends that cross 2024 are approximate. A physician-owned practice, the reader this paper is written for, describes a large minority of physicians in the 2024 figure and not a majority11. We think that has a practical consequence: where a hospital system, a private equity owner or a management company sits above the practice, decisions about the website, the telephone line and the tracking tags may be made elsewhere, and the owner's first task is to know where.
The Bureau of Labor Statistics' Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages counted 239,840 private-sector establishments in offices of physicians in 2024, with 2,954,911 employees on annual average12. That is about 12.3 employees per establishment (2,954,911 / 239,840), a mean across every role and size of office that describes no particular office. We expect an office of about a dozen people to have little staff to spare for marketing work, which is why Chapter 5 asks where technology can release staff time. The Bureau also counts 862,800 physician and surgeon jobs in 202513; that is a different unit from establishments, and we do not divide one by the other.
Most of those offices are small. In the first quarter of 2024 the Bureau counted 237,573 private-sector establishments in offices of physicians14, of which 138,197 had fewer than 5 employees15 and 39,896 had 5 to 916. That is 58.2% of the establishments with fewer than 5 employees (138,197 / 237,573) and 75.0% with fewer than 10 (178,093 / 237,573). Size here is employees at one location and not in the firm, and owners with no employees are not counted, so the figures describe offices and not practices. The first-quarter count and the annual average above are different figures and are not set against each other. We infer that an office with fewer than 5 employees has few people to answer the telephone, book, remind and recall.
Costs are the other side of the business. In a June 23, 2026 poll by MGMA (the Medical Group Management Association), 84% of medical groups reported year-to-date operating costs higher than at the same point in 2025, on 251 applicable responses17. A poll of 251 does not speak for every practice, so we use it only as a sign of direction. MGMA's DataDive analysis reports that from 2011 to 2024 median total operating cost per FTE (full-time-equivalent) physician rose 71.6% in physician-owned multispecialty groups and 83.3% in hospital- or IDS-owned peers, while the CPI (consumer price index) rose 39.5%18. Relative to the CPI that is a rise of about 23% in physician-owned groups (1.716 / 1.395) and about 31% in the hospital- or IDS-owned peers (1.833 / 1.395).
We think physician time is the input a practice can least afford to leave idle. The Bureau reports a median annual wage for physicians and surgeons of $275,930 in May 202513. A wage is not the full cost of an employed clinician and says nothing about what an owner earns, so we use it only for scale: an unfilled appointment slot is clinician time already paid for.
How patients choose a physician: coverage, people and ratings
Most of what is known about how patients choose a physician comes from surveys. In the one academic survey of the US public that we cite, fielded in September 2012, 65% of adults were aware of online physician ratings, below their awareness for cars (87%) and for non-healthcare service providers (71%)4. The survey also asked how important various factors were in selecting a primary care doctor; Table 2 gives the share who rated each factor very important.
| Factor | Rated very important |
|---|---|
| Whether the physician accepts one's health insurance (primary care doctor) | 89%4 |
| Word of mouth from family and friends (primary care doctor) | 38%4 |
| Referral from another physician (primary care doctor) | 34%4 |
| Physician ratings on websites (choosing a physician) | 19%4 |
Table 2. Share of respondents rating each factor very important in a September 2012 survey of the US public. The factors overlap, so the shares do not add up.
Coverage came first. Whether a physician accepted the respondent's health insurance was rated "very important" most frequently, at 89%, when choosing a primary care doctor4. We think coverage works as a filter before it works as a preference: a physician who does not take a patient's plan is outside that patient's choice, however well regarded, so a plain statement of the plans a practice accepts is among the most useful things a page can say. In addition, 47% rated word of mouth from family and friends somewhat important4. For ratings websites, 40% said "somewhat important," and the survey reports that rating sites were endorsed less frequently than other factors4.
Trust in the ratings was a separate matter: 43% of respondents who had not sought online physician ratings reported a lack of trust in the information on the sites19. Three cautions apply to all of these figures. The survey is from 2012, so it cannot describe how patients choose now. Most items in Table 2 concern primary care doctors, and the survey does not say whether a specialist's patients, or a med spa's, choose the same way. And a stated rating of importance is not a record of a decision.
A Pew survey fielded in 2012 found that about one in five internet users had consulted online reviews of drugs or treatments, doctors or other providers, or hospitals, and it gives no share for doctors alone20. Press Ganey† (patient experience) reports in a 2024 blog that 83.5% of consumers with a referral in hand at least occasionally turn to online reviews to validate it21. Its 2021 consumer survey (secondary, through a medical society's summary) reports that a search engine was the most common online resource for researching a provider, at 65.4%22, and that 84% would not see a referred provider rated under 4 stars, a stated intention and not an observed choice22. Press Ganey† does not describe its sampling.
The one behavioral study is peer reviewed. At a single large specialty practice in the New York and New Jersey area, mean new-patient volume fell 2.3% to 2.6% after a 1-star review, an association in observational data from one practice and not a trial23. Chapter 2 returns to ratings.
Access is part of choice: who gets an appointment
A patient who has chosen a physician still needs the office to offer an appointment, and audit studies show that offers differ by who is asking24,25. In a simulated-patient telephone study of primary care practices in 10 states between November 2012 and April 2013, 84.7% of privately insured callers and 57.9% of Medicaid callers received a new-patient appointment24. Uninsured callers received appointments 78.8% of the time when full cash payment was possible, but only 15.4% of the time if payment required at the visit was restricted to $75 or less24. Among callers who obtained an appointment, the median wait was typically less than 1 week, or 2 weeks in Massachusetts, with no difference by insurance status or urgency of health concern24.
A 2011 paired secret-shopper audit of specialty clinics found a similar pattern: of 273 clinics, 66% of Medicaid-CHIP callers were denied an appointment, against 11% of privately insured callers25. Among the 89 clinics that accepted both insurance types, the average wait for Medicaid-CHIP enrollees was 22 days longer than for privately insured children25. The two studies cover different patients, years and kinds of office, so we report them as two observations, not one trend.
Nor do these studies sit on one scale with the 31 days of the AMN survey: Rhodes and colleagues report a median among callers who got an appointment, AMN an average across six specialties in 15 large metro areas in 20251. The instruments count different things, and setting their figures side by side would manufacture a trend that neither supports.
Other studies measure whether a caller reached anyone. Across Veterans Health Administration medical centers in October 2014, the mean abandonment rate, calls ended by the caller before a staff member answered, was 12.0%26, and by September 2016 it was 8.3%26; those are government call centers, not private offices. Invoca† (call tracking) reports that a person answered 54% of inbound calls to healthcare organizations in six sub-fields, among them dental, hospitals and physical therapy27. Call Box† (call tracking and answering) reports that the rate of patient callers connected to a qualified individual fell from 73% in 2019 to 63% in 2020 across more than 1,700 US health care practices28. In an Ohio State University secret-shopper study of psychiatrists and psychologists listed in insurance directories in five states, more than 6 in 10 calls reached an automated system or answering machine and could not be analyzed29.
These are different measures in different settings, so we do not average them, and none covers private physician offices as a group. They show that reaching someone is not guaranteed. A practice's own rate comes only from its own call counts, as Chapter 6 describes.
Access belongs to the choice because quality is hard for a patient to judge. In his model of used cars, Akerlof described an asymmetry in which sellers know more about quality than buyers do30, and he listed the licensing of doctors among the institutions that reduce quality uncertainty30. Dulleck and Kerschbamer's survey of credence goods asks under which conditions experts such as doctors have an incentive to exploit the informational problems of diagnosis and treatment31. The full argument is in the economics of choosing a professional. We think a patient who cannot judge clinical quality leans on what can be observed: the plan accepted, the opinion of people trusted, and how easily the office responds. The practice controls the third.
Scheduling decides who is admitted, by policy and by whoever answers. This paper takes no view on which plans a practice should accept; that is a business decision for the owners and, where rules apply, for their counsel.
Medical marketing and healthcare marketing: what owners and administrators search for
Our keyword data shows how often people search for phrases that a practice owner, an administrator or a vendor would use. Table 3 lists the medical and healthcare phrases in that data with average US searches a month and average cost per click, from Google Ads keyword data for November 2026.
| Search phrase | Searches a month | Average cost per click |
|---|---|---|
| hipaa compliant ai32 | 6,600 | $41.88 |
| healthcare marketing agency32 | 5,400 | $25.17 |
| medical answering service32 | 5,400 | $35.92 |
| medical marketing agency32 | 4,400 | $42.16 |
| healthcare marketing32 | 1,600 | $25.48 |
| healthcare crm32 | 720 | $42.99 |
| healthcare advertising32 | 590 | $27.05 |
| medical marketing32 | 590 | $22.21 |
| patient engagement32 | 590 | $12.10 |
| medical seo32 | 390 | $24.68 |
| medical spa marketing32 | 390 | $77.61 |
| medical website design32 | 390 | $69.76 |
| healthcare seo32 | 320 | $64.48 |
| medical practice marketing32 | 320 | $87.76 |
| doctor marketing32 | 170 | none reported |
| medical practice seo32 | 170 | $27.81 |
| patient acquisition32 | 170 | $36.38 |
| ai medical receptionist32 | 140 | $80.76 |
| healthcare digital marketing32 | 140 | $42.61 |
| ai in healthcare marketing32 | 110 | $23.96 |
| physician marketing32 | 90 | none reported |
| hipaa marketing rules32 | 70 | $1.57 |
| how to get more patients32 | 70 | $34.11 |
| hipaa compliant marketing32 | 40 | $26.65 |
| new patient marketing32 | 10 | none reported |
Table 3. Medical and healthcare phrases in our keyword data: average US searches a month and average cost per click, November 2026. The phrases are searches, not descriptions of any tool or service.
The vendor phrases are searched more often than the discipline phrases: "healthcare marketing agency" is searched about 3.4 times as often as "healthcare marketing" (5,400 / 1,600)32, and "medical marketing agency" about 7.5 times as often as "medical marketing" (4,400 / 590)32. The vocabulary is also scattered: "medical practice marketing" draws about 320 searches a month32, "doctor marketing" about 17032 and "physician marketing" about 9032, so no single phrase gathers the field. And questions about the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) concern AI far more than marketing: "hipaa compliant ai" is searched about 94 times as often as "hipaa marketing rules" (6,600 / 70)32. The two phrases differ in form, so the comparison is rough, but we infer that the compliance worry attaches to AI tools and that the rules on marketing are looked up far less.
The phrases are ones a practice owner or a vendor would type, not ones a patient would, so the table says nothing about what patients search for. Volume shows interest, not purchase. Cost per click is what advertisers pay, not what a patient is worth: the highest in Table 3, "medical practice marketing," is about $87.76 a click32, a price for the phrase and not the value of any patient. The largest volume in the table is about 6,600 searches a month for the whole United States32, so medical marketing is a niche topic as a search.
We use patient engagement for the communication between a practice and its existing patients: reminders, follow-up and portal messages. We use healthcare CRM for software that records each contact with a patient or prospective patient and where that contact stands. Whether a CRM can hold patient information is a question about business associate agreements; Chapter 4 reports which common tools sign one in our check.
How to get more patients: patient acquisition and access
The thesis of this paper is that access to a physician is uneven, and that marketing for a medical practice is mostly about access. A practice can be short of appointments, with an average new-patient wait of 31 days in AMN's survey1, and still lose the callers who reach no one and the visits that are booked and missed. We do not claim this for every practice: it describes a practice with a wait and a leak.
For such a practice marketing does three jobs. It gets the practice found by the patients it wants to serve, it gets calls answered, and it keeps the visits that are booked, through reminders, recall and the refilling of canceled slots.
Extra demand is still worth having, and we think it takes four forms. A patient who fills a slot left empty by a cancellation or a missed visit turns a lost visit into a kept one. A practice with more inquiries than openings can choose which to book first, by service, insurer or site, and payments differ by payer: for most specialties the median payment per visit in 2016 was highest for privately insured patients and lowest for patients on Medicaid9. A self-pay line such as a med spa can raise its minimum price when inquiries exceed what it can serve. And demand that stays above what the physicians can see is the case for adding a clinician.
Where openings are scarce, marketing includes selection. A practice with a queue chooses which demand to serve, whether it says so or not: by service line, insurer, site or physician. If it does not choose deliberately, the choice is made by whoever reaches the telephone first and by the rules the front desk applies, and the audit studies above show that such rules can produce very different outcomes for callers with different coverage24,25. Choosing deliberately means building the pages, listings and messages for the demand the practice wants and can serve, and saying plainly which plans it accepts.
The second and third jobs keep the patients who are already trying to get in. A patient who calls and does not reach the office, who books and does not attend, or who attends once and is not recalled has cost the practice whatever it spent to produce the first contact. A primary care physician had a mean of 51.1 appointments a week in Epic health-system data from 202133, which is 221 scheduled appointments a month (51.1 x 52 / 12), including the visits that are missed. At the missed-visit rates above, 18.8% to 23%, that is 42 to 51 missed visits a month for one physician and 167 to 204 for four. These are a scale and not a forecast, because the rates come from a VA system and a review across settings and the volume from health systems. Each missed visit is a slot the practice has already staffed.
A practice with open new-patient slots is in a simpler position: the chapters on search, ratings and AI answers apply with full force, and its test is its own number, the days a new patient waits for the next open appointment, which Chapter 6 uses as the measure of access.
What the plan has to bring in: a primary care example
A worked example shows the size of the demand a plan has to produce. Its inputs are cited and its sums are shown in brackets; it is not a forecast of what any plan will do. The plan costs $999 a month at the lowest tier8, and because it carries no patient information a medical practice can buy it with no HIPAA program10. The National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey, in 2019, estimated 320.7 physician office visits per 100 persons34, and 50.3% of office visits were made to primary care physicians34. A person made 1.61 primary care visits a year (3.21 x 50.3%). New patients accounted for 12.5% of primary care office visits35, a share of visits and not of patients. Of one physician's 221 scheduled appointments a month, 171 to 180 are kept at the missed-visit rates above, or 682 to 719 of the 886 for four physicians. 12.5% of kept visits is 21 to 22 new-patient visits a month for one physician (12.5% x 171 to 180) and 85 to 90 for four (12.5% x 682 to 719).
What a primary care patient brings in comes from the payment per visit. The mean payment per primary care office visit was $186 in 20169, so 1.61 visits is $300 a year in payments (1.61 x $186). That is an average over everyone, including people who made no visit, so we expect a person who seeks a practice out to bring more. The median relationship between a patient and a primary care physician was 8 years in one study of 799 patients aged 65 and over in Oklahoma36, which is $2,400 in payments over 8 years ($300 x 8). That describes older patients in one state around 2000, so Table 4 shows the first year, three years and 8 years side by side.
| One physician | Four physicians | |
|---|---|---|
| Appointments a month (scheduled) | 221 | 886 |
| Kept visits a month, once 18.8% to 23% are missed | 171 to 180 | 682 to 719 |
| New-patient visits a month now, at 12.5% of kept visits | 21 to 22 | 85 to 90 |
| New patients a month needed to cover $999, first year only | 3.3 (15.6% more) | 3.3 (3.9% more) |
| The same, counting three years of payments | 1.1 | 1.1 |
| The same, counting 8 years | 0.4 | 0.4 |
Table 4. The $999 plan set against new primary care patients (calc. from the cited inputs), at the 2016 mean payment of $186 a visit. The percentage is the extra new patients as a share of the new-patient visits a month now.
The mean is pulled up by costly visits, so the count depends on which payment per visit is used. Table 5 uses three levels: the 2016 median for a primary care visit, $1079; the 2016 mean of $186 used above; and the 2023 mean for a visit to any medical doctor, $34737, which includes costly specialty visits and so overstates a primary care visit.
| Payment per visit | A patient's payments in a year | New patients a month to cover the plan, first year |
|---|---|---|
| Median primary care visit, 2016: $107 | $173 | 5.8 |
| Mean primary care visit, 2016: $186 | $300 | 3.3 |
| Mean visit to any medical doctor, 2023: $347 | $560 | 1.8 |
Table 5. The $999 plan at three payment levels (calc. from the cited payments and 1.61 primary care visits a year).
At the mean, the plan alone is covered by 3.3 new patients a month on a first-year count, or 1.1 if patients stay three years, and by 5.8 at the 2016 median. The count is the same for four physicians because the plan costs the same; what changes is its share of the new patients already arriving, as the last column of Table 4 shows. For a solo physician 3.3 is about 16% more new-patient visits than the practice has now (Table 4). Payments are what insurers and patients paid, not what the practice keeps after the cost of the visit, so a new patient who needs added capacity adds less than the payment, and a practice should use its own margin. This paper does not measure how many new patients a plan produces. The practice's own count answers that, and Table 4 gives the number it has to reach.
Our interest in the argument
We sell services in this area, and a reader should weigh the argument knowing so. Technical Marketing's plans are priced at $999, $1,999 and $2,999 a month for one location, and each additional location is $299 a month8. A 12-month term paid in full is two months free, at $9,990, $19,990 and $29,990 a year (a saving of $1,998, $3,998 and $5,998). The two lower plans carry a one-time onboarding fee of $499 and $999 and the $2,999 plan a $3,000 setup fee; a 12-month term waives the two onboarding fees and cuts the setup fee to $1,4008. The AI voice agent is priced at $299 a month with 250 call minutes included, then $0.39 a minute8. HIPAA-ready programs are priced at $1,500 setup plus $699 a month (Essentials) and $3,500 setup plus $1,199 a month (Integrated), per location, after a compliance consultation10. A program is a compliance layer added to a plan and does not include the voice agent, which is a separate add-on10. Current prices are on our pricing page and the programs are described on our HIPAA page.
The paper treats what a practice buys as one system: the plan produces demand, the agent answers it, and for a medical practice the program is the compliance layer for the tools that touch patient information. Four front-desk add-ons run inside a program10. We think the program is bought for service, speed of answer and more hands at the front desk, and for the layer that lets that service run on patient information.
Each part is set against what it produces: the plan against new patients, as in Table 4, the agent against answered calls, kept visits and front-desk hours, and the program against the service that runs on it. Chapter 5 states the one corner in which the system loses money and how far the cited base rates put a practice from it.
The term HIPAA-ready, and not compliant, is ours because whether an office's use of a tool complies is for the practice and its counsel to establish, not for a vendor to declare. This paper reports no client results or testimonials, and its evidence is public sources plus our own data. Nothing in the argument depends on buying from us: a practice can act on each chapter's design requirements with its own staff or another provider.
The map of this paper
The through-line of the paper is found, chosen, reached, within the rules, measured. Chapter 2 covers how a practice is found in local search and in AI answers, and what our study of AI answers leaves out: it did not ask about physicians. Chapter 3 turns the HIPAA marketing rule, the tracking-technology guidance, the FTC's actions and the rules on reviews into design requirements for a site, a campaign and a review program, and says which marketing practices touch patient information.
Chapter 4 treats the telephone as the place where access is won or lost, and the front desk response and the AI receptionist covers the front desk in general. Chapter 5 asks where AI pays in a medical practice and what it requires, and Chapter 6 shows what a practice can count without sending patient data to an advertising tool, with a first 90 days in order; the longer treatment is in measurement and attribution for a small practice.
The later chapters carry the arithmetic that this chapter began. The agent inside a HIPAA-ready program is a purchase of service, set against kept visits and front-desk hours and not against new patients, and a four-physician practice covers it with under one point off its no-show rate. Solo primary care is the tight case: it needs nearly three points off the no-show rate (calc., Chapter 5), the top of the 0.5 to 3 points found in two reminder studies, a before-and-after comparison at one VA medical center and a randomized trial at one clinic2,38. Chapters 4 and 5 work through it.
Chapter 2
Medical SEO and healthcare SEO: search, ratings and AI answers
Google's help page for local businesses sets the terms for medical SEO: it says local results are mainly based on relevance, distance and popularity39, and that there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking39.
Medical SEO and local ranking: what Google says it ranks
We use medical SEO for the work of making a practice's pages and listings visible when people search for care, and healthcare SEO for the same work across a wider range of organizations. In our keyword data, "medical seo" draws about 390 searches a month at an average cost per click of $24.68, "healthcare seo" about 320 at $64.48, and "medical practice seo" about 170 at $27.8132. As Chapter 1 noted, owners and vendors type these phrases, not patients.
Google's Business Profile page adds that popularity also draws on how many websites link to a business and how many reviews it has, and that more reviews and positive ratings can help a business's local ranking39. This is Google's own description of its system and not an independent measurement of ranking weights, and "mainly" means the three factors are the main ones and not the only ones.
We think the three factors divide what a practice can do. Distance is fixed by where the practice is. Popularity, through reviews and links, can be earned over time. Relevance, the match between what the practice says it does and what the patient typed, is where a practice has most say. A study of mobile local search adds that the first screen counts: its authors found that ranking effects were higher on mobile phones, so that links at the top of the screen were especially likely to be clicked40, and that stores in close proximity to a user's home were much more likely to be clicked on mobile phones40. The study is from 2013, concerns mobile local search for stores and says nothing about medical care, so we cite it for the mechanism and not for an effect size that would transfer to physicians.
Two vendors put numbers on how clicks fall with position. Sistrix† reports in a 2020 keyword study an average click-through rate of 28.5% for the first organic position in Google and 2.5% for the tenth, on a keyword set that is not restricted to local or professional searches41. Backlinko† reports in a 2023 analysis of Google organic search results that the first organic result has an average click-through rate of 27.6% and is ten times more likely to receive a click than a result in tenth position42. The claims we cite do not describe either as specific to medicine, and we do not rest the importance of position on them: the mobile study carries that point, and these two figures only illustrate its size.
Healthcare SEO and AI features: what Google says, and what happens to clicks
Google states that a page must be indexed and eligible to be shown in Google Search with a snippet to appear as a supporting link in AI Overviews or AI Mode, and that there are no additional technical requirements43. It also says that no specific optimization is required for either feature and that existing SEO fundamentals "continue to be worthwhile"43. An earlier Google page, dated 2024 in our record, makes the same point44.
We infer that Google's position is that eligibility is the entry requirement and ordinary good practice is the whole of its advice. The statements say nothing about how Google chooses among eligible pages or about other assistants. Our study did not test Google's AI Overviews: it put questions to ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity through each assistant's application programming interface (API)45.
Pew Research Center compared Google visits with and without an AI summary, using US adults' browsing data46. Table 1 gives two of its comparisons.
| Measure | With an AI summary | Without an AI summary |
|---|---|---|
| Visits in which the user clicked a traditional search result link | 8%46 | 15% |
| Pages after which the user ended the browsing session entirely | 26%46 | 16% |
Table 1. Pew Research Center's 2025 comparison of Google visits and search pages with and without an AI summary.
The Pew dataset contains 68,879 unique Google searches, of which 12,593 produced an AI summary46. That is about 18% of searches (12,593 / 68,879). In Pew's browsing analysis, 88% of the summaries cited three or more sources and only 1% cited a single source46. We think the source count matters as much as the share: a summary that cites several sources leaves room for more than one site to be named, though nothing here says which. The claims we cite do not limit either Pew result to local or medical queries, so we treat both as general results.
Three vendors report higher shares for health queries, each on a query set of its own. Conductor† (SEO software) found AI Overviews on 48.7% of page-one Google queries for Health Care in a four-week window in September and October 202547. SE Ranking† (SEO software) found them on 196 of 300 health keywords (65.33%) in data from September 2024, keywords its authors chose48. Whitespark† (local SEO) ran 540 queries by hand in Houston, Phoenix and Denver across six industries, among them dentists and medical clinics, and found AI Overviews on 15% of local-intent queries against 92% of informational-intent queries49. A patient's search for a nearby physician is a local-intent query, so Whitespark†'s figure is the closest of the three. It is a May 2025 snapshot of three cities in a product that Google changes often, and none of the three measures searches for physicians.
Surveys of adults show how many put health questions to a chatbot. In a Pew survey fielded in February 2026, 20% of US adults said they ever use AI chatbots to get medical advice50. In a later Pew survey, from June 2026, 15% cited helping decide whether to see a doctor as a reason they use chatbots for health; the report frames its reasons as shares of Americans, and the sentence does not state the base51. A KFF poll fielded in February and March 2026 found that about a third of adults (32%) had turned to AI chatbots in the past year for health information52, and 42% of those who asked about physical health said they did not follow up with a doctor or other health professional afterward52. These are self-reports of use: they show that some patients ask a chatbot before they ask a practice, not that any of them asked it to name a physician.
Several further figures support no conclusion alone. SparkToro† (audience research software) analyzed clickstream panel data and reports that 58.5% of American Google searches in 2024 ended in zero clicks53. BrightLocal† (local SEO) reports in its 2025 survey that 6% of consumers used ChatGPT or other AI tools to find local reviews, down from 9% in 202454, and in its 2026 survey of 1,002 US adults that use of generative AI tools for local recommendations rose from 6% to 45%55. The two surveys are separate panels and the question wording is not printed, so a change in wording may account for part of a jump of more than seven times. A separate study found that ChatGPT's consumer product had been adopted by around 10% of the world's adult population by July 202556, a worldwide figure that says nothing about local search or health.
AI referrals to health sites are small in the one dataset we cite. Conductor† reports that AI referral traffic was 0.64% of all website traffic for Health Care across its enterprise customer domains from May to September 2025, with ChatGPT the source of 83.8% of those referrals47. Those domains are not medical practices, and a referral count misses an answer that names a practice and sends no click. These measures are not added together.
Our study of AI answers: what it shows, and what it leaves out for physicians
Our study put 199 local questions to ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity across 16 US cities and 23 kinds of business on November 10, 2026, collecting 597 answers through each assistant's API with web search on45. The method is argued in how AI assistants recommend dentists, doctors, lawyers and accountants, and the data are in our study with its data. Two limits apply throughout. On method, each question was asked once, names were matched across assistants by spelling, up to eight names were read per answer, and answers through an API are a baseline, not what every signed-in user sees45. On scope, the study does not show that any assistant is wrong, that a named business is good, or that a cited page caused a name to appear.
A third limit matters most here: our study did not ask about physicians. It asked about chiropractors and med spas in 16 cities and about physical therapists in 345. None is a physician practice, so we use their rows as the nearest evidence and nothing more. Table 2 gives the three rows and the study totals.
| Row in our study | Cities | Businesses named | Named by all three | Named by only one |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chiropractors45 | 16 | 228 | 10 (4.4%) | 80.3% |
| Med spas45 | 16 | 228 | 13 (5.7%) | 79.4% |
| Physical therapists, three cities, a small sample45 | 3 | 51 | 1 (2%) | 78.4% |
| Ten kinds asked in all 16 cities, 160 questions45 | 16 | 2,414 | 84 (3.5%) | not reported here |
| All questions45 | 16 | 2,975 | 122 (4.1%) | 79.7% |
Table 2. The rows of our study nearest to a physician practice, with the study totals. None of the first three rows is a physician practice, and the physical therapist row rests on three cities.
160 questions across ten kinds is 16 questions a kind (160 / 10), one for each city, so the chiropractor and med spa rows rest on 16 questions each45. The physical therapist row rests on 3 questions (51 names / 17 per question)45. Agreement among the assistants was low in all three rows (Table 2), and the med spa and chiropractor rows sit close to the totals, though not close to every row in the study: for dentists in the same 16 cities, 3 of 266 businesses named (1.1%) were named by all three assistants45. Agreement varies by kind of business, so a physician row could sit above or below these.
The same pattern appears question by question. In 108 of 199 questions (54%), no business was named by all three assistants45. All three named the same business first in 9 of the 199 questions, and at least two agreed on the first name in 7545. The assistants also behave differently. ChatGPT (model gpt-6-luna) named 4.8 businesses and cited 3.5 websites per answer on average and cited Reddit in 2% of its answers45. Gemini (model gemini-3.8-flash) named 6 and cited 6.5, with Reddit in 42% of its answers45. Perplexity (model sonar) named 7.8 and cited 7.7, with Reddit in 0%45. We infer that a practice named by one assistant has learned something about that assistant and little about the others.
The 597 answers cited 1,455 different websites, for 3,530 citations in all45, and 88% of the websites cited were cited by only one assistant45. The 25 most-cited websites drew 29% of all citations, and each was cited in at least 9 of the 16 cities; they are directories, review platforms, list sites, publishers and a forum, not any one local business's site45. The most-cited site, reddit.com, appeared in 87 answers45. Websites cited in only one city, where a local business's own site would fall, drew 39% of citations45.
Because each question was asked once, a second asking might have named different businesses. We estimate that it would have, so each row in Table 2 is one draw and not a ranking (from the study below; likely high, as a small city with few candidates may repeat its lists more often). SparkToro†'s 2026 study, with Gumshoe.ai†, had 600 volunteers run 12 prompts through ChatGPT, Claude and Google's AI, 2,961 runs in all57. It reports less than a 1 in 100 chance that the tools, asked a prompt 100 times, would give the same list of brands in any two responses57, and less than 1 in 1,000 for the same list in the same order, even in spaces with limited options such as Los Angeles Volvo dealers57.
SparkToro†'s study is not peer reviewed, its author discloses a possible conflict of interest, and its prompts were not about doctors, dentists, lawyers or accountants. A repeat-asking study of AI recommendations for local businesses or professional practices is NF; the nearest evidence is SparkToro†'s57.
Two inferences follow. First, because the sites assistants cite most include directories and review platforms, what those platforms say about a practice is part of what an assistant can see about it, though our study does not show that a cited page caused a name to appear. Second, the assistants disagree with each other and each question was asked once, so nothing in the study supports a promise that a practice will be named, and we make none.
AI in healthcare marketing: what studies of AI on medical questions do and do not show
A cited source is not proof that the source says what the answer says. A 2023 audit of commercial generative search engines found that, on average, 51.5% of generated sentences were fully supported by citations and 74.5% of citations supported their associated sentence58; the claim as we cite it does not say the audit was specific to health questions. We think the consequence for a practice is that an assistant can cite the practice's page and misstate it, and can misstate the practice without citing it. A practical response is to read what the assistants say about the practice and keep its own facts clear and current.
In a 2023 JAMA Internal Medicine cross-sectional study of 195 public patient questions posted to Reddit's r/AskDocs, licensed health professionals preferred an AI chatbot's response to the verified physician's response in 78.6% of 585 evaluations3. The evaluators compared written answers to forum questions, not a chatbot inside a practice, and a preference between two written answers is not a measure of accuracy or safety. Another 2023 study found that ChatGPT performed at or near the 60% accuracy passing threshold for all three exams of the United States Medical Licensing Examination59.
The most direct test of how people use a chatbot on medical scenarios was randomized. In a Nature Medicine study published in February 2026, the language models tested alone correctly identified the underlying condition in 94.9% of ten medical scenarios and the right course of action in 56.3% on average60. UK participants who used the same models identified relevant conditions in fewer than 34.5% of cases and the course of action in fewer than 44.2%, no better than a control group60. The gap between the models alone and the people using them is the finding. The study used a UK sample and the models of its time, which may differ from current ones, and it concerns how people use a chatbot for their own health questions, not which practice an assistant recommends.
Neither result answers the question that matters to a practice's marketing. Passing an examination does not show that an assistant knows which insurance a particular office accepts or whether it is taking new patients. Our own study asked who is a good business of a given kind in a given city45, a question about recommendation and not clinical content. This paper gives no clinical advice and takes no position on how AI should answer clinical questions; it treats AI answers as a channel through which patients may learn of a practice and asks what the practice controls in that channel.
Generative engine optimization: what the research found and its limits
We use generative engine optimization, or GEO, for changing content so that generative engines are more likely to show it. Searches for the topic run to about 4,400 a month for "generative engine optimization" at an average cost per click of $35.0432, and to about 2,400 a month for "answer engine optimization" at $21.3132. Neither phrase is specific to medicine.
The paper that introduced the term reports that its methods can raise a source's visibility in generative engine responses by up to 40%61. The same paper reports that the efficacy of its strategies varies across domains, which its authors say shows the need for "domain-specific optimization methods"61. It also describes generative engines as black boxes in which content creators have "little to no control over" when and how their content is displayed61.
The limits are in those same sentences. A figure given as "up to" 40% is a ceiling, not a typical gain61. The quantity measured is visibility in responses, not appointments. The paper is from 2023, and none of the GEO claims we cite shows a technique tested on a medical practice or says whether health was among the domains tested, so we cannot say what the methods would do for one. That is consistent with Google's statement that no special optimization is required for its own AI features43.
We think GEO is a reason to keep the fundamentals complete and consistent, not a lever. The fundamentals are covered in the next two sections: accurate listings, a page for each service, plan and place, and a steady supply of honest reviews. A claim to guarantee placement in AI answers conflicts with the GEO authors' own statement that creators have little to no control61.
Ratings as a signal for physicians
In the September 2012 US survey described in Chapter 1, usage of online physician rating sites was 23%, against awareness of 65%4. Among respondents who had sought ratings in the past year, 35% reported selecting a physician based on good ratings and 37% had avoided a physician with bad ratings4. Respondents acted on ratings in both directions. The share avoiding a physician with bad ratings (37%) was slightly the larger, though the survey's 95% confidence intervals (28% to 43% and 29% to 45%) overlap4. The survey is from 2012 and the base is the subset who sought ratings, so these are not shares of all patients.
A 2012 analysis of ratings on RateMDs found a mean of 3.93 on a scale of 1 to 5, and among rated physicians 45.80% received a perfect 5 out of 5 while only 11.76% of ratings were below 262. We infer that, if ratings cluster near the top of the scale, a high rating separates few physicians from the rest and a low one stands out. The distribution does not show how patients use low ratings, and it concerns one rating site in one period.
One peer-reviewed study links ratings to new-patient volume for physicians. It analyzed 1.12 million new patient appointments and 12,882 physician reviews at one large single-specialty practice in the New York and New Jersey area, and found that mean new patient volume decreased 2.3% to 2.6% following a 1-star review, with effects lasting at least 16 weeks23. Only 6.7% of the reviews were 1-star23. The study covers one practice in one metro area and one specialty, so it is not a sample of physicians, and it is a before-and-after comparison, not a trial. The finding concerns 1-star reviews only.
Outside medicine, a 2016 study of Yelp ratings for restaurants in one city found that a one-star increase led to a 5-9% increase in revenue for independent restaurants, with no effect for restaurants that were part of a chain63. We think a restaurant meal is judged soon after it is bought, while a physician is chosen under the information problems described in Chapter 1, so the restaurant result is a contrast and not a basis.
BrightLocal†'s 2024 survey reports that 75% of consumers always or regularly read online reviews when researching local businesses and that 3% never do64. It covers local businesses in general, and the claim that reviews matter does not rest on it: Google's own page says reviews and positive ratings can help local ranking39, and some respondents to the 2012 survey reported acting on ratings4.
We think the practical task is to earn honest ratings from all patients, satisfied or not. Chapter 3 covers the rules on replying to reviews, including enforcement cases in which replies disclosed patient information.
Medical practice SEO: what a practice controls
Table 3 sorts the levers in medical SEO by what the sources we cite say about each.
| Lever | What the sources say | Within the practice's control? |
|---|---|---|
| Distance from the searcher | Google lists distance among the three main factors in local results39 | Set by where the practice is |
| Paying for local rank | Google says there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking39 | Not available |
| Reviews and links to the site | Google says the popularity factor draws on both, and that more reviews and positive ratings can help39 | Partly: earned over time (Chapter 3 describes the rules on buying reviews) |
| Being indexed and eligible for a snippet | Google says this is the requirement to appear as a supporting link in AI Overviews or AI Mode43 | Yes, through the web provider |
| Plans accepted, stated on a page | Insurance acceptance was rated very important by 89% in a 2012 US survey, for a primary care doctor4 | Yes |
| Listings on directories and review platforms | In our study, which did not ask about physicians, the 25 most-cited websites were directories, review platforms, list sites, publishers and a forum45 | Partly: the practice can keep its own entry accurate |
| What an assistant says and shows | The GEO authors say content creators have little to no control61 | No |
Table 3. Levers in medical SEO, what the sources we cite say about each, and whether the practice controls it.
Web design starts with system design, and the system here is a set of questions the pages must answer. We think a patient brings these: which services the practice provides, where, with which physician, and under which plans. The Business Profile, the directory entries and the website should give the same answer to each. Each service, plan and location the practice wants to serve deserves a page of its own, because in the 2012 US survey plan acceptance was the factor respondents rated very important most often when choosing a primary care doctor4, and because a general page cannot say which plans apply at which site. Searches for the design of such pages run to about 390 a month for "medical website design" at $69.76 a click32. The order of work is the questions first and the layout second.
We expect a physician page to be where a patient checks whom they will see. Akerlof named licensing, including the licensing of doctors, as one of the institutions that reduce quality uncertainty30. A page can support that work in a small way by stating what a patient can verify elsewhere: the physician's licensure and training, the services the physician provides and the plans the physician accepts. Claims about quality or results are a different matter; Chapter 3 describes what the AMA's opinion and the FTC's health guidance say about them.
A page that answers and offers to book turns a visit into access, which Chapter 1 argued is part of choice. A page that collects patient information through a form, a chat window or a scheduling widget also raises the questions about tracking technologies that Chapter 3 covers, and Chapter 6 covers counting what the page produces. We think the first item to settle is eligibility: Google says a page must be indexed and eligible to be shown in Search with a snippet43, and the practice's web provider can confirm that service pages meet that condition. The practice cannot control how an assistant words its answer, which assistants its patients use, or where a searcher is standing.
Chapter 3
Healthcare advertising under HIPAA: marketing, tracking and reviews
This chapter describes three sets of texts: the HIPAA Privacy Rule's definition of marketing, the federal and state rules on health data that reaches advertising tools, and the rules on reviews and testimonials. It reports what each says as the texts print it and reduces them to design requirements for a site, a campaign, a tag and a review program. Chapter 4 takes up the telephone, and Chapter 6 takes up how to count results without sending patient data to an advertising tool.
In Google Ads data for November 2026, searches for "healthcare advertising" averaged about 590 a month in the US at $27.05 a click, "hipaa marketing rules" about 70 at $1.57 and "hipaa compliant marketing" about 40 at $26.6532. These are phrases an owner or a vendor would type, not a patient; volume shows interest, not purchase, and cost per click is what advertisers pay. We do not describe any campaign or tool, ours included, as "HIPAA compliant marketing"; Chapter 4 gives the reasons.
Which marketing practices touch patient information
Marketing alone needs no HIPAA program. We sell our marketing plans to health care practices without one because a plan carries no patient information10, so the least a medical practice can buy is a plan at $999 a month8. A page that describes services, a directory listing and an advertisement aimed at searchers carry none of their own. That is how we scope our service; whether a particular item is protected health information is for the practice's counsel.
Other marketing practices do touch patient information, because they can tell that a named person is a patient. In our scoping these need a program: appointment forms, texts to patients, and call tracking and recordings10. Tracking on booking or portal pages belongs beside them. A recorded call holds a voice and whatever the caller says about their care.
A HIPAA-ready program is the compliance layer for those tools. It does not include the voice agent, which is a separate add-on10. Four front-desk add-ons run inside a program10. We frame the program as service, speed of answer and more hands for the front desk, and as the layer that lets that service run on patient information.
Healthcare advertising and the HIPAA marketing rule
The Privacy Rule defines marketing, in general, as making a communication about a product or service that encourages recipients of the communication to purchase or use it, and the definition opens with the words "Except as provided in paragraph (2) of this definition"65. This paper does not list the paragraph (2) exceptions. The texts turn on two questions: whose information a message uses, and who pays for it.
A covered entity must obtain an authorization for any use or disclosure of protected health information for marketing, except where the communication is face-to-face or is a promotional gift of nominal value provided by the covered entity5. HHS's guidance page says that, generally, a communication that is marketing can occur only if the covered entity first obtains the individual's authorization66. The same page says covered entities may not sell lists of patients or enrollees to third parties without obtaining authorization from each person on the list66.
The Privacy Rule also defines financial remuneration as direct or indirect payment from or on behalf of a third party whose product or service is being described, and says that payment for treatment of an individual is not included65. This paper gives the definition of that term, not the paragraph that uses it.
We think the marketing rule is a rule about data and about payment. Whether a campaign uses protected health information is a fact about the campaign: which list it was built from, which tool holds that list and what the tool does with it. Whether someone else pays for the message is a fact about a contract. We expect the audience definition to be the costly part of a defensible campaign, because a list drawn from patient records raises the authorization question directly, and an audience built from website visits raises the tracking question of the next section. Our paper on professional practices compares the four rulebooks, medicine's among them.
HIPAA and online tracking technologies on a medical practice website
The HHS Office for Civil Rights (OCR) published a bulletin on tracking technologies, and an archived copy shows its original content was last reviewed on December 1, 202267.
The bulletin says that tracking technologies on many unauthenticated webpages do not have access to individuals' protected health information, in which case a regulated entity's use of them is not regulated by the HIPAA Rules, while in some cases such technologies may have access to that information6. It gives an example: if an individual makes an appointment through the website of a covered health clinic and the site uses third-party tracking technologies that send the appointment and the IP address to a vendor, the tracking vendor is a business associate and a business associate agreement is required6.
It says regulated entities may not use tracking technologies in a way that results in impermissible disclosures of protected health information to tracking technology vendors, and it names disclosures to those vendors for marketing purposes, without authorizations that comply with HIPAA, as an example6. It also says that banners asking users to accept or reject cookies do not constitute a valid HIPAA authorization, and that it is insufficient for a tracking vendor to agree to remove protected health information from what it receives6.
A court has since vacated part of this guidance. In American Hospital Association v. Becerra, on June 20, 2024, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas declared unlawful what it called the Proscribed Combination in HHS's bulletin of March 18, 2024, as promulgated in clear excess of HHS's authority under HIPAA6,68. It described that combination as circumstances where an online technology connects an individual's IP address with a visit to an unauthenticated public webpage addressing specific health conditions or healthcare providers68. The court denied a permanent injunction but granted vacatur68, and wrote in a footnote that the vacatur is not intended to limit the legal operability of other guidance in the same HHS document68.
HHS's bulletin page now says the court vacated the guidance only to the extent it provides that HIPAA obligations are triggered in those circumstances6. On those two texts the bulletin was not vacated as a whole: HHS's page names one element, and the footnote above says the vacatur is not intended to limit other guidance6,68. HHS's appointment example is a different situation from the vacated element6. We think treating the ruling as permission for any tag on any page reads more into it than the court wrote, and treating the bulletin as a ban on every tag reads more into it than HHS wrote. Which of a practice's pages fall on which side is counsel's call.
Our own design takes the cautious reading where it matters: we leave advertising and analytics tags off booking, portal and symptom pages. That is a design choice, not a reading of the ruling, and it matches our HIPAA-ready program, which keeps ad pixels and standard analytics off pages and tools that handle patient information. We do not call the result compliant, because compliance is the practice's to establish. In our check of 28 software tools, four offer no business associate agreement according to the vendors' own pages, and two of the four are Google Analytics and Meta Pixel69. Whether a given tool on a given page falls within HHS's appointment example, where the tracking vendor is a business associate and an agreement is required6, is for counsel. Our check of which tools sign a BAA lists all 28.
Health data and the FTC: proposed orders and the Health Breach Notification Rule
Table 1 sets out four FTC announcements of proposed orders involving consumers' health data.
| Firm | Announced | What the FTC said | Money in the proposed order |
|---|---|---|---|
| GoodRx | February 1, 2023 | Shared sensitive personal health information for years with advertising companies and platforms, contrary to its privacy promises, and failed to report the disclosures as the Health Breach Notification Rule requires70 | A $1.5 million civil penalty, in what the FTC called its first enforcement action under that rule70 |
| BetterHelp | March 2, 2023 | Used and revealed consumers' email addresses, IP addresses and health questionnaire information to Facebook, Snapchat, Criteo and Pinterest for advertising71 | $7.8 million to consumers71 |
| Easy Healthcare (Premom app) | May 17, 2023 | Violated the Health Breach Notification Rule72 | A $100,000 civil penalty72 |
| Cerebral | April 15, 2024 | Provided sensitive information of nearly 3.2 million consumers to third parties such as LinkedIn, Snapchat and TikTok by using or integrating tracking tools on its website or apps73 | Nearly $5.1 million for partial refunds to consumers impacted by deceptive cancellation practices, plus a $10 million civil penalty suspended after a $2 million payment73 |
Table 1. FTC announcements of proposed orders involving health data, as the FTC described them. For GoodRx, BetterHelp and Cerebral the conduct column gives allegations in the FTC's complaint, and for all four the money column gives what a proposed order would require.
The Health Breach Notification Rule, 16 CFR part 318, does not apply to HIPAA covered entities, or to any other entity to the extent that it engages in activities as a business associate of a covered entity74. The FTC announced on April 26, 2024 that it had finalized changes clarifying that the rule applies to health apps and similar technologies not covered by HIPAA75, and the amendments took effect on July 29, 202474. As amended, a breach of security includes an unauthorized acquisition of unsecured PHR identifiable health information in a personal health record that occurs as a result of a data breach or an unauthorized disclosure74.
Table 1 describes announcements about the firms named and says nothing about what a medical practice may do. Two points come from the texts. In the GoodRx and BetterHelp announcements the FTC charged that health information went to advertising companies or platforms, contrary to GoodRx's privacy promises and after BetterHelp promised to keep the data private70,71. And the line between HIPAA and the FTC's rule is drawn by kind of entity, as the exclusion above shows74,75. Which side a practice's cash-pay line, app or medical spa brand falls on is a question for its counsel.
State law and consumer health data: Washington as one example
States can write their own rules for consumer health data, and Washington has76. We use its My Health My Data Act as one example of the type, not as a survey of state law.
The Act defines consumer health data as personal information that is linked or reasonably linkable to a consumer and identifies the consumer's past, present or future physical or mental health status76. As printed, the collection section carries a date of March 31, 2024 and bars a regulated entity or small business from collecting consumer health data except with consent for a specified purpose or to the extent necessary to provide a product or service76. Sharing needs consent that is separate and distinct from the consent to collect, unless it is necessary to provide a product or service the consumer requested76. A separate subsection sets June 30, 2024 as the date from which a small business must comply with that section76. The Act defines a small business by thresholds, one of which is consumer health data of fewer than 100,000 consumers in a calendar year76.
Information that meets the definition of protected health information under HIPAA and related regulations falls outside the Act76. Sorting what a practice's website collects into the two groups is counsel's work.
A violation of the Act is an unfair or deceptive act in trade or commerce for the purpose of Washington's Consumer Protection Act, chapter 19.86 RCW76. Under RCW 19.86.090 a person injured in business or property by a covered violation may sue in superior court to enjoin further violations and recover actual damages plus costs and a reasonable attorney's fee, and the court may increase damages up to three times actual damages, with the treble increase under RCW 19.86.020 capped at twenty-five thousand dollars76. This paper does not say how that mechanism applies to a claim under the Act.
Review replies and OCR's enforcement matters
HHS's page, last reviewed June 5, 2023, says Manasa Health Center, a New Jersey psychiatric provider, paid $30,000 to OCR and agreed to a corrective action plan over a response to a patient's negative online review77. The resolution agreement says Manasa impermissibly disclosed the protected health information of four patients in response to their negative reviews on Google Reviews78. The page describes the payment as resolving "potential violations," so the agreements recite allegations, and we describe them as such77.
Three dental practices appear in OCR's materials for the same pattern. In an announcement dated October 2, 2019, OCR said Elite Dental Associates of Dallas agreed to pay $10,000 and adopt a corrective action plan to settle potential violations of the HIPAA Privacy Rule79. The resolution agreement recites a complaint that the practice, replying to a patient's Yelp review on June 4, 2016, disclosed her last name, details of her treatment plan, and insurance and cost information80. It says OCR's review found the practice had also disclosed other patients' protected health information when answering their reviews without valid authorizations80. Among the covered conduct OCR listed was a failure to implement policies and procedures with respect to protected health information, including releasing it on social media or public platforms80.
New Vision Dental of California paid $23,000 and agreed to a corrective action plan, on a page last reviewed December 14, 202281. Its agreement recites a complaint that the practice habitually disclosed protected health information when it responded to patient posts, sometimes providing full names where patients had used only Yelp monikers and including detailed information about patient visits and insurance82. The third matter, involving Dr. U. Phillip Igbinadolor, D.M.D. & Associates in North Carolina, was not a settlement. OCR imposed a $50,000 civil money penalty after the practice, which had disclosed a patient's protected health information on a webpage in response to a negative online review, did not respond to OCR's data request or an administrative subpoena and waived its rights to a hearing83.
Every matter above concerns a reply the practice wrote to a review a patient had posted, and the disclosure recited is the practice's own reply, not the patient's review. We know the matters only through HHS's summaries and the agreements, and none gives a model of a safe reply: the materials describe what was disclosed, not what a reply may say. We think a reply program needs three rules: a template that contains no patient-specific detail, no reply that goes beyond what the reviewer wrote, and privacy-officer review before any other reply posts. Whether even confirming that a reviewer is a patient is a disclosure is a question for counsel, and the OCR materials do not answer it.
Asking a patient for a review is a different act from replying to one. We think a request sent to a known patient uses the fact that the person is a patient, which is why we scope a text request with the other texts to patients10; whether the request is also a marketing communication under the definition above is for counsel. HHS or OCR text on asking a patient for a review is NF: the search returned only commentary on responding to reviews. The nearest texts are the definition of marketing and the reply matters above.
The FTC rule on fake and bought reviews
The second set of texts on reviews is the FTC's Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, 16 CFR part 465, which took effect on October 21, 202484. Section 465.2 makes it an unfair or deceptive act for a business to write, create or sell a consumer review or testimonial that materially misrepresents that the reviewer exists, that the reviewer used the product or service, or the reviewer's experience85. The FTC said the rule addresses reviews and testimonials that misrepresent that they are by someone who does not exist, such as AI-generated fake reviews86.
Section 465.4 covers a business providing compensation or other incentives in exchange for reviews expressing a particular sentiment, whether positive or negative87. Section 465.7 covers using an unfounded or groundless legal threat, a physical threat, intimidation or a knowingly false public accusation in response to a review in an attempt to prevent it from being written or to have it removed88. In warning letters of December 22, 2025, the FTC said violations can bring civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation89.
The FTC sections address how reviews are obtained and what is done about unwelcome ones87,88; the OCR matters concern what a practice said back. We think a review program has to be read against both: a reply with no patient detail could still carry the kind of legal threat that section 465.7 describes, if the threat is unfounded or groundless.
HIPAA civil money penalty tiers
HHS publishes the civil money penalty range for each of four levels of culpability in an inflation-adjusted table90,91. Table 2 gives the per-violation range for each level from the table HHS published on January 28, 2026 (the 2025 adjusted figures), beside the annual limit HHS said in a notice published April 30, 2019 that it would apply, before inflation adjustment.
| Culpability level | Per violation, 2025 adjusted | Annual limit in HHS's 2019 notice |
|---|---|---|
| Did not know, and by reasonable diligence would not have known | $145 to $73,01190 | $25,00091 |
| Reasonable cause and not willful neglect | $1,461 to $73,01190 | $100,00091 |
| Willful neglect, corrected within 30 days | $14,602 to $73,01190 | $250,00091 |
| Willful neglect, not corrected within 30 days | $73,011 to $2,190,29490 | $1,500,00091 |
Table 2. HIPAA civil money penalty amounts by culpability level: the 2025 adjusted per-violation range, published January 28, 2026, and the annual limit in HHS's 2019 enforcement-discretion notice, before inflation adjustment.
Before the 2019 notice, HHS's Enforcement Rule applied an annual upper limit of $1.5 million to each of the four levels91, so the notice lowered the limit for the first three91. The January 2026 table prints a calendar-year cap of $2,190,294 for the top level90. This paper does not check whether later HHS action has altered any of these figures, and a practice should confirm the current ones before it relies on them.
What the AMA and the FTC say about advertising claims and testimonials
Opinion 9.6.1 of the AMA's Code of Medical Ethics says there are no restrictions on advertising by physicians except those that can be specifically justified to protect the public from deceptive practices92. It is an opinion in a code of medical ethics, not a statute or rule. On testimonials it advises that patients' statements about a physician's skill or the quality of professional services tend to be deceptive when they do not reflect the results that patients with comparable conditions generally receive92.
The FTC's Health Products Compliance Guidance, dated December 2022, says that as a general rule claims about the health benefits or safety of foods, dietary supplements, drugs and other health-related products require substantiation in the form of competent and reliable scientific evidence93. It also says advertisers should not make claims through consumer testimonials or expert endorsements that would be deceptive or could not be substantiated if the advertiser made them directly93, and that advertisers are liable for the misleading use of endorsements, whether in traditional media, on the internet, in social media or in other forms of marketing94.
That guidance is written for health-related products. Whether it reaches a practice's claims about clinical services is not decided here, and we use it only as a reference point for how the FTC approaches health claims. The tests differ: the FTC asks whether a claim would pass if the advertiser made it directly, the AMA whether a testimonial reflects what comparable patients generally receive. We think a page that shows only the most glowing outcomes is hard to defend under either.
State advertising rules for physicians: California and Texas as two examples
We read the California sections on a legal publisher's reproduction labeled current as of January 1, 2026, which may lag the official text, and the Texas rule on a reproduction that shows an amendment effective January 9, 2025.
In California, Business and Professions Code section 651(b)(8) lists as false, fraudulent, misleading or deceptive any statement, endorsement or testimonial that is likely to mislead or deceive because of a failure to disclose material facts95. The section does not ban testimonials. Section 651(h)(5)(C) lets a physician and surgeon licensed by the Medical Board of California state that the practice is limited to specific fields, but not that the physician is certified or eligible for certification by a board unless the board is an American Board of Medical Specialties member board or meets one of the other tests the statute lists95. Section 2271 makes advertising that violates section 17500, the false-advertising statute, unprofessional conduct for physicians96.
Texas Medical Board rule 22 TAC 164.3(b)(3) deems it false, deceptive or misleading advertising for a physician to provide a testimonial without a disclaimer or warning as to the credentials of the person making it and a disclosure of any compensation provided in exchange for it97. Rule 164.3(b)(1) deems the terms "board eligible" and "board qualified," or similar language calculated to convey the same meaning as "board certified," false, deceptive or misleading97. Whether a review that a patient posts on a third-party site, or a practice's reuse of it, is a testimonial under these texts is for counsel.
Design requirements for a site, a campaign, a tag and a review program
Table 3 reduces the texts above to design requirements for six surfaces. Each is a constraint we would build to.
| Surface | What the texts say | Design requirement |
|---|---|---|
| Service, insurer and physician pages | Testimonials tend to be deceptive if they do not reflect comparable results92; health claims need substantiation93; Texas requires a credentials disclaimer and a compensation disclosure on a physician testimonial97 | Each claim about results can be substantiated if challenged. Testimonials are chosen and labeled so that they imply no more than comparable patients generally receive, and carry the disclosures the practice's state requires. Board certification is stated only as the state permits. |
| Booking, intake and login pages | HHS's example of a patient booking through a clinic's site, with tracking technologies sending the appointment and IP address to a vendor, makes the vendor a business associate6; a cookie banner is not an authorization6 | No advertising or analytics tag. A tag from a vendor that has signed a business associate agreement is a separate decision, not a default. A consent banner is never treated as the authorization. |
| Other public pages | Tags on many unauthenticated pages lack access to protected health information, though some may have it6; one element of the bulletin was vacated6 | A list of every tag by page type and vendor, reviewed when it is made and again when HHS or a court changes the guidance. |
| Campaign audiences | Authorization for uses or disclosures of protected health information for marketing5; no sale of patient lists without authorization66; a defined term for third-party payment65 | No patient list goes to an advertising platform. A message that draws on patient information, or that a third party pays for, is not built until the authorization and payment questions are answered. |
| Review requests | No incentive in exchange for reviews of a particular sentiment87; no fake reviews85 | A request asks for a review, not a good review, and offers nothing in return. Nobody writes a review under another name. A request sent by text to a patient is a text to a patient and runs inside a program in our scoping10. HHS or OCR text on asking a patient for a review is NF; the nearest texts are the marketing definition and the reply matters. Whether the request is itself a marketing communication is open. |
| Review replies | OCR matters concern replies that disclosed patient information78, in two of them names, treatment plan, insurance, cost or visit details80,82; the FTC rule covers unfounded or groundless legal threats made to prevent or remove a review88 | A template with no patient detail, no reply that goes beyond the reviewer's own words, privacy-officer review of anything else, and no threats. |
Table 3. Design requirements by surface, with the texts each draws on. The requirements are our design stance and no ruling on a practice.
Chapter 4
Medical answering service and AI medical receptionist: the phone, HIPAA and disclosure
This chapter treats the telephone as the place where a medical practice's access is won or lost, and describes an answering design built around HIPAA and the disclosure laws, with its cost set against kept visits, front-desk hours and unanswered calls.
The medical answering service and who reaches the practice
Table 1 gives the November 2026 demand for the phrases this chapter answers.
| Search phrase | US searches a month | Cost per click |
|---|---|---|
| ai receptionist32 | 74,000 | $43.66 |
| hipaa compliant ai32 | 6,600 | $41.88 |
| medical answering service32 | 5,400 | $35.92 |
| ai answering service32 | 4,400 | $58.48 |
| ai medical receptionist32 | 140 | $80.76 |
Table 1. Average US monthly searches and average cost per click, Google Ads keyword data, November 2026.
These are phrases an owner, an administrator or a vendor would type, not a patient; volume shows interest, not purchase, and cost per click is what advertisers pay. The general phrase draws far more searches than the medical one, and we make nothing of the gap, since search volume cannot separate a medical office's query from anyone else's. One phrase, "hipaa compliant ai", asks for a status; what the HHS texts say about such labels is below.
An answering service is a function before it is a product: someone or something picks up when the front desk cannot. A practice can be short of appointments and still lose patients and visits it could have kept: a caller hangs up before anyone answers, a patient who cannot move a visit does not come, a slot opens late and stays empty. The phone carries four kinds of call. A patient moving a visit opens a slot. One asking to be seen needs a place on a list or an honest answer. One with a clinical question needs a message that reaches the right person. One who may be unwell needs a route to a human, not a voicemail box. We think the design is therefore about speed of answer and routing.
In a 2012 to 2013 telephone study of primary care practices in 10 states, 84.7% of privately insured callers and 57.9% of Medicaid callers received a new-patient appointment24. That audit measures whether callers with different insurance got appointments, not how often offices answer24. A 2026 secret-shopper study led by Ohio State University researchers (news release) called 5,822 psychiatrists and psychologists listed in commercial insurance directories in five states and could not analyze more than 6 in 10 calls, because those calls reached an automated system or answering machine and no person29. That is mental health only, and the numbers came from insurance directories; a call that was picked up led to an appointment 24% of the time29. Chapter 1 sets out the access evidence, and our paper on professional practices treats the front desk in depth.
Published measures of unanswered calls exist, and they measure different things. In October 2014 the mean abandonment rate, calls ended by the caller before a staff member answered, was 12.0% across Veterans Health Administration medical centers, with a mean speed of answer of 87.1 seconds26. By September 2016 the VA figures were 8.3% and 69 seconds26, against a VA goal of 30 seconds or less and 5% or less26. The authors found that speed of answer, not the abandonment rate, was associated with patients' ratings of their ability to get urgent-care appointments in time26. These are VA call centers, not private physician offices.
The other measures come from vendors. Invoca† (call tracking) reports that 54% of inbound calls to healthcare organizations in its data were answered by a person, across six healthcare fields: behavioral health and rehab, dental, eye care, hearing, hospitals and physical therapy27. Call Box† reports that at more than 1,700 US healthcare practices the rate of patient callers connected to a qualified individual fell from 73% in 2019 to 63% in 202028. CallMyDoc† reports that 33.1% of 4,687,808 inbound calls to 297 practices on its own answering platform were abandoned before the caller selected a call type98, which means leaving its menu, not an unanswered ring. Ended before a staff member answered, answered by a person, connected to a qualified individual and left the menu are four different measures, and none should be averaged with another.
For private physician offices, ~8.3% to 46% of calls reach no person (from the VA's 8.3% in 2016 and 100% less Invoca†'s 54% answered by a person; likely low at the bottom end). A small office with no queue sends an unanswered call to voicemail, and the VA measure counts only calls that a caller ended while waiting. A measurement of unanswered calls at private physician offices themselves is NF; the nearest evidence is the VA and vendor measures above.
Appointment reminders, no-shows and what the trials found
A 2018 systematic review of 105 studies of no-shows in healthcare appointment scheduling found an average no-show rate of the order of 23%, highest in Africa at 43.0% and lowest in Oceania at 13.2%3. With a spread that wide, the number that matters is the practice's own count of appointments offered and kept, which Chapter 6 shows how to take.
A 2013 Cochrane review found moderate-quality evidence from seven trials (5841 participants) that mobile text message reminders improved attendance at healthcare appointments compared with no reminders, with a risk ratio of 1.14 (95% confidence interval 1.03 to 1.26)3. In the pooled trials attendance was 67.8% with no reminders, 78.6% with mobile phone messaging reminders and 80.3% with phone call reminders3. That is 10.8 percentage points more attendance with messaging reminders than with none (78.6% - 67.8%), and 12.5 with phone calls (80.3% - 67.8%). Two studies reported that the cost per attendance of text message reminders was 55% and 65% lower than for phone call reminders3. The authors wrote that the evidence remains insufficient to conclusively inform policy decisions3.
One randomized quality-improvement initiative at a safety-net primary care clinic added model-driven live reminder calls to standard automated reminders for appointments with a predicted no-show risk of 15% or higher. The no-show rate in the augmented group was 33% against 36% in the standard-care group (p < 0.01), a difference of 3 percentage points38.
In one VA system a centralized phone reminder lowered the no-show rate from 16.3% to 15.8%, a before and after comparison, not a randomized one2. A 2026 meta-analysis of 10 randomized trials of reminders for hospital outpatient appointments, in nine countries, found a pooled risk ratio for attendance of 1.11 (95% confidence interval 1.05 to 1.19)99. The no-show rate itself is high: the mean was 18.8% across the 10 main clinics of one VA medical center over fiscal years 1997 to 20082, and the review above puts the average at about 23%. The VA comparison and the safety-net initiative put the change in the no-show rate at 0.5 points and 3 points; Chapter 5 uses that range, and it is the only effect size this chapter claims for reminders.
None of these studies shows whether an AI voice agent that answers inbound calls changes attendance. For a practice whose agent also confirms and rebooks visits, the change in the no-show rate is ~0.5 to 3 points (from the phone reminders above; likely high, because answering a call is not sending a reminder). A randomized or field study of an AI agent answering inbound calls or scheduling in a medical office is NF; the nearest peer-reviewed work is outbound: at Mount Sinai in 2025, an AI voice assistant making pre-procedure calls completed 86.4% of its calls in the first phase of a study of 1,606 calls to 1,431 patients100. That is a guide to what a voice agent can finish, not a measure of a front desk. An AI voice that places reminder or callback calls is a different design problem with a different consent rule, taken up under the FCC's ruling below.
Business associates: who is one and what the agreement must contain
HHS describes a business associate as a person or organization that performs functions or activities on behalf of a covered entity that involve creating, receiving, maintaining or transmitting protected health information101. A subcontractor that does the same on behalf of another business associate is itself a business associate101. A service that records who called a medical practice and why is, at the least, a vendor to test against that definition; whether a given arrangement makes it a business associate is for counsel.
A covered entity may disclose protected health information to a business associate, and may allow it to create, receive, maintain or transmit that information on its behalf, if the covered entity obtains satisfactory assurance that the business associate will appropriately safeguard it102. HHS describes the assurances as coming in the form of a contract or other written arrangement101, and the regulation requires them to be documented in a written contract or other written agreement that meets the requirements of 45 CFR 164.504(e)102. That section says the contract must establish the permitted and required uses and disclosures of protected health information by the business associate, and may not authorize uses or disclosures that would violate the Privacy Rule if the covered entity did them, with narrow exceptions for the associate's own management and data aggregation103.
HHS publishes sample business associate agreement provisions, and states that using the sample language is not required for compliance and may not alone be sufficient to form a binding contract under state law104. A vendor's statement that it signs agreements is therefore the start of a conversation.
On certification, HHS says that no standard or implementation specification in the Security Rule requires a covered entity to "certify" compliance7. It also says it does not endorse or otherwise recognize private organizations' "certifications" regarding the Security Rule, and that such certifications do not absolve covered entities of their legal obligations under that rule7. Both statements concern the Security Rule, and we keep that scope. Our conclusion: a vendor's label of compliance is the vendor's own claim, and the cited texts show no HHS status behind it. We apply no such label to ourselves or to any tool. We say HIPAA-ready, which describes a setup built under a signed agreement and leaves open whether the result meets the practice's obligations.
Which common tools sign a business associate agreement
In November 2026 we checked 28 software tools that small practices commonly use against each vendor's own pages. Nine will sign a business associate agreement without requiring a special tier, 15 sign one only on certain plans and 4 offer none69. Table 2 shows the groups.
| Group | Tools | Count |
|---|---|---|
| Sign an agreement without a special tier | Not named here69 | 9 |
| Sign an agreement only on certain plans | Includes ChatGPT, Gmail, Claude and Twilio69 | 15 |
| Offer no agreement | Zapier, Calendly, Google Analytics, Meta Pixel69 | 4 |
Table 2. The 28 tools in our check, by whether the vendor's own pages offer a business associate agreement, November 2026.
Six of the 15 plan-gated tools do not publish the price of the plan that qualifies for an agreement69, leaving nine that do (15 - 6). A practice costing out a stack of such tools has to ask for quotes on the other six. The full table is in our report.
The check records what vendors say on their own pages and does not test whether an agreement is adequate, whether a tool is configured correctly, or whether a tool suits a medical practice.
A voice agent of this kind would chain several services: a telephone carrier, a speech component, a language model, a place to keep the call record, and a connection to a calendar. We read HHS's wording about subcontractors as a reason to put each link that handles protected health information in the agreement chain101. Our HIPAA-ready design signs an agreement with each service in the chain, and no patient calls are handled before they are signed.
Telling a caller they are speaking to an AI
Table 3 sets out the state laws and the medical-association policy we cite on disclosing AI, with the limits each source states. Whether any of them reaches an AI that answers a medical office's inbound call is for counsel.
| Text | What it says | Limits the sources state |
|---|---|---|
| California Health and Safety Code 1339.75 (AB 3030) | A health facility, clinic, physician's office or group practice office that uses generative AI to generate patient communications about patient clinical information must include a disclaimer that the communication was AI-generated and clear instructions for reaching a human105; for audio, the disclaimer is given verbally at the start and the end of the interaction105 | Patient clinical information excludes appointment scheduling, billing and other clerical or business matters105; the requirements do not apply if a human licensed or certified provider reads and reviews the communication105 |
| California Business and Professions Code 17941 | Unlawful to use a bot to communicate or interact with another person in California online with intent to mislead about its artificial identity, in order to incentivize a purchase or sale or to influence a vote105; no liability if the person discloses that it is a bot, clearly and conspicuously105 | Covers a bot communicating online; whether a telephone voice agent is covered the source does not answer105; operative July 1, 2019105 |
| Utah Code 13-77-103 | A supplier using generative AI in a consumer transaction must disclose that the individual is interacting with generative AI and not a human, if the individual asks or otherwise prompts106; an individual providing services in a regulated occupation must prominently disclose AI use in the provision of regulated services if it is a high-risk AI interaction106, verbally at the start of a verbal interaction106 | The prompt must be a clear and unambiguous request106; high-risk includes collecting sensitive personal information such as health data107; a regulated occupation is one regulated by the Department of Commerce that requires a license or state certification107 |
| Texas Business and Commerce Code 552.051(f) | The provider of a health care service or treatment in which an AI system is used must give the disclosure to the recipient or personal representative not later than the date the service or treatment is first provided, or as soon as reasonably possible in an emergency108 | Effective January 1, 2026108; the general disclosure in 552.051(b) is addressed to a governmental agency108 |
| AMA policy adopted November 12, 2024 | Where patients engage directly with AI used by hospitals, health systems, physician practices or other entities, the use should be clearly disclosed at the beginning of the interaction, and AI-generated patient-facing content should be disclosed within the content109 | A policy position, not law |
Table 3. Disclosure texts in our evidence for AI used in patient or consumer communications. Statutes are described as printed; the AMA text is policy.
We give no operative date for the California health-care statute. Utah's general duty waits for the caller to ask, and its duty for regulated occupations in high-risk interactions is not conditioned on asking. Utah also provides a safe harbor from enforcement if the generative AI clearly and conspicuously discloses, at the outset and throughout the interaction, that it is generative AI, is not human or is an AI assistant110.
Our design discloses at the start, the point several of these texts name105,106,109. The agent says in words that it is an AI assistant at the start of every call, whatever the call turns out to be about. We think that is better than deciding call by call whether a call has become clinical, because a caller who begins with a scheduling request can end with a symptom. Whether some states also require a closing statement is open.
In a Gartner survey of 5,728 customers in December 2023, 64% said they would prefer that companies did not use AI in their customer service111, and 53% said they would consider switching to a competitor if they found out a company was going to use AI for customer service111. The survey is an analyst firm's own and concerns customers in general, not patients. We read it as a reason to pair the disclosure with an easy route to a person, not to withhold it, since the texts above and the AMA's policy point the other way.
The one field experiment we cite on voice AI replacing a phone menu is from a large telecommunications company, where replacing its IVR, the automated phone menu, with a voice-based AI system temporarily increased machine-service duration and customers' demand for human service, and persistently reduced customer complaints112. Those customers were not patients.
We expect an agent to finish a little over a third of inbound calls without staff (from the outbound calls above, where 36.6% of the Phase I calls, and 42.6% of the Phase II calls, were fully automated and needed no human intervention100; likely high, because a scripted call to a patient who expects it is easier to finish than a call that arrives with any question). A peer-reviewed containment rate for an AI agent on inbound calls is NF; the nearest evidence is those outbound figures.
Relatient† (patient scheduling) said in an August 2025 release that its voice AI product answered 62% of inbound calls, of which 72% were either autonomously handled or escalated within the organizations113. Handled or escalated is not containment, because that 72% includes calls passed to staff113, and the release describes no sample.
Recording calls and AI-generated voices
Federal law makes it not unlawful for a private person to intercept a communication where the person is a party to it or one party has given prior consent, unless the purpose is committing a criminal or tortious act114. Washington makes it unlawful to intercept or record a private communication transmitted by telephone or other device without first obtaining the consent of all the participants76. California punishes a person who intentionally and without the consent of all parties to a confidential communication uses an electronic recording device to record it105, with a fine not exceeding $2,500 per violation, or imprisonment, or both105. We think recording is the practice's decision, since the three texts above differ on whose consent is required.
The FCC's Declaratory Ruling FCC 24-17, adopted February 2, 2024 and released February 8, 2024, confirmed that the Telephone Consumer Protection Act's restrictions on an "artificial or prerecorded voice" encompass current AI technologies that generate human voices115. The FCC said calls that use such technologies require the prior express consent of the called party to initiate, absent an emergency purpose or exemption115. The consent requirement is stated for initiating such calls, and we do not say that it extends to an AI agent answering an inbound call.
That ruling matters for the outbound half of the phone, where an AI voice places reminder or callback calls. The TCPA's private-action provision, 47 U.S.C. 227(b)(3), lets a person bring a state-court action for actual monetary loss or $500 in damages for each violation, whichever is greater, and a court may increase the award for a willful or knowing violation to not more than three times that amount116. Whether a given call would be a violation is for counsel. The service described here is answering calls; outbound AI calling is a separate matter to clear with a lawyer first.
What the agent may do and what stays with clinical staff
We sell the agent to a medical office only inside a HIPAA-ready program, after a compliance consultation10. The consultation maps what patient information the calls would touch and what they never need to touch. The practice signs a business associate agreement with us, every service in the chain signs one with us, and we test with synthetic records, never real patients. The agent does not diagnose, triage or comment on symptoms. Table 4 shows how the calls divide. The medical-office page describes the same design.
| Call | What the agent does | What stays with the practice |
|---|---|---|
| A new patient asking to be seen | Checks the visit types the practice accepts, offers openings from its calendar, takes a name and a callback number | Which patients are seen sooner, and any clinical judgment |
| A patient moving a visit | Offers other times and confirms the change; does not read back or discuss anything about the patient's health | Patients' records and anything clinical |
| A refill or lab result request | Writes the request down for clinical staff | Looking up, giving or commenting on results |
| Hours, location and accepted insurance | Answers from the practice's website and the list it supplied; if a plan is not on the list, says so and takes a message | Which plans the practice accepts and any exceptions |
| A billing question | Takes a name and number and leaves the message for billing staff | The answer |
| A caller who may be unwell | Follows the rule set at the consultation: tells an emergency caller to dial 911 and rings the named on-call person | Every decision about urgency |
Table 4. The division of calls between the AI voice agent and the practice's staff, as our medical-office design sets it.
Texts to staff say that a call came in and what action it needs, and they carry no health information. The agent gives no medication, dosing or test-result information. It does not replace the front desk: it picks up when the desk is closed, at lunch or buried in calls.
A tribunal decision illustrates why the scope is narrow. In Moffatt v. Air Canada, 2024 BCCRT 149, issued February 14, 2024, a British Columbia tribunal found the airline liable for negligent misrepresentation because its website chatbot told a customer he could apply for bereavement fares retroactively117. It wrote that the airline is responsible for all the information on its website, whether from a static page or a chatbot117. The decision is a British Columbia tribunal's and concerns an airline, so we cite it for a design lesson, not as a rule for a US medical office: an agent should state only facts the practice supplied, such as hours and accepted plans, and should say it does not know when the supplied list does not cover the question.
What an AI medical receptionist costs
A plan alone is marketing, and it needs no HIPAA program. We sell plans to health care practices without a program because a plan carries no patient information10, so the least a medical practice can buy is a plan at $999 a month8. The agent is a different purchase: it answers patient calls, which touches patient information, so it runs inside a HIPAA-ready program, a compliance layer added to a plan that does not include the agent10. The site assistant, appointment forms, texts to patients and call tracking each need the same layer, and the front-desk add-ons priced below run inside it10. The agent is $299 a month with 250 call minutes included, then $0.39 a minute8, and Essentials, the lower program, is $1,500 setup plus $699 a month per location10.
The agent's 250 included minutes are about 62 four-minute calls (250 / 4), and $0.39 a minute applies after them. Every case in this chapter stays inside the included minutes, so the agent's fee here is its published $2998. Spreading the $1,500 setup over the first 12 months comes to $125 a month, so Essentials is $824 a month in the first year ($699 + $125) and $699 after. Table 5 gives each purchase and what it is set against.
| What is bought | Monthly cost | Set against |
|---|---|---|
| A plan alone: the marketing, with no patient information | $999 | New patients |
| The agent, added to a plan the practice already has, with 250 call minutes included | $299 | Answered calls and front-desk hours |
| HIPAA-ready Essentials, first year: the compliance layer that every tool handling patient information runs inside, not part of the agent | $824 | Everything that runs on it; no single gain is asked to carry it |
| Essentials after the first year | $699 | The same |
| Essentials and the reminders add-on, first year ($824 + $149) | $973 | Kept visits |
| The agent and Essentials, first year: the narrow case of a practice with no program that buys one for the agent and runs nothing else on it | $1,123 | The agent's gains only: answered calls and front-desk hours |
| Lowest plan, agent and Essentials together, first year | $2,122 | New patients, kept visits and front-desk hours |
| The same after the first year | $1,997 | New patients, kept visits and front-desk hours |
Table 5. Monthly cost of each purchase for one location (calc. from the published prices on monthly billing): the lowest plan at $999, the agent at $299 with 250 call minutes included, Essentials at $699 and the $1,500 setup spread over 12 months ($824 in the first year), and reminders at $149. The sums are $1,123 for the agent and Essentials in the first year ($299 + $824), $2,122 for the lowest plan, agent and Essentials in the first year ($999 + $299 + $824) and $1,997 after it ($999 + $299 + $699). A costlier plan adds the difference between plan prices.
Plans are $999, $1,999 and $2,999 a month for one location, and each additional location is $299 a month8. The two lower plans carry a one-time onboarding fee of $499 and $999, and the top plan a $3,000 setup fee. A 12-month term paid in full is two months free, at $9,990, $19,990 and $29,990 a year (a saving of $1,998, $3,998 and $5,998); a 12-month term also waives the two onboarding fees and cuts the setup fee to $1,4008. The table does not use a 12-month term paid in full. Past the 250 included minutes, a four-minute call costs $1.56 (4 x $0.39)8. A practice that wants a connection to its scheduling or practice-management system may want the Integrated program, at $3,500 setup plus $1,199 a month per location10. Current prices are on our pricing page.
The plan is set against new patients. A primary care patient's payments are $300 in a year (3.21 physician office visits per person a year34 x the 50.3% of those visits made to primary care34 x a 2016 mean payment of $186 a primary care visit9). That $300 is an average over everyone, including people who made no visit34, so a person who seeks a practice out is likely to bring more.
The $999 plan needs 3.3 new patients a month counting their first year only ($999 / $300). A physician has 221 scheduled appointments a month (calc. from 51.1 a week in Epic data33), and 171 to 180 of them are kept once 18.8% to 23% are missed. Of the kept visits, 12.5% are new patients' visits in primary care35, which is 21 to 22 a month, so 3.3 is 15.6% more for one physician and 3.9% more for four, who have 85 to 90. Counting three years of a patient's visits, the plan needs 1.1 new patients a month, and counting 8 years, the median stay in the one study of patients aged 65 and over36, it needs 0.4. Chapter 5 sets out these inputs and their limits.
An agent is a service purchase. We think it is bought for speed of answer and more hands at the front desk, so its $299 a month is set against front-desk hours and the answered calls in Table 7. The program around it is shared by everything that handles patient information, and reminders are what the two no-show studies measured, so the program and the reminders add-on together, $973 a month ($824 + $149), are set against kept visits10. Table 6 sets both against a one-physician and a four-physician practice, at the no-show rates in the studies above.
| One physician | Four physicians | |
|---|---|---|
| Appointments a month | 221 | 886 |
| Missed visits a month at 18.8% to 23% | 42 to 51 | 167 to 204 |
| What one point off the no-show rate is worth a month | $412 | $1,647 |
| Kept visits needed to cover the program and reminders ($973 a month) | 5.2 (2.4 points off the no-show rate) | 5.2 (0.6 points off) |
| Kept visits needed to cover reminders alone, where the program is already in place ($149 a month) | 0.8 | 0.8 |
| Kept visits if no-shows fall by 0.5 to 3 points | 1.1 to 6.6 ($206 to $1,236) | 4.4 to 26.6 ($824 to $4,942) |
| The agent's fee ($299 a month) in front-desk hours, at $34.59 an hour | 8.6 a month (about 25 minutes a working day) | 8.6 a month (about 25 minutes a working day) |
Table 6. The program and reminders set against kept visits, and the agent set against front-desk hours (calc.): $186 a primary care visit9, 51.1 appointments a week for each physician33, no-show rates of 18.8% and 23%2,3, a 0.5 to 3 point change from reminders2,38, $973 a month for the program and reminders ($824 + $149), $299 a month for the agent, with 250 call minutes included, and $34.59 an hour118.
To cover the program and reminders, $973 a month, takes 5.2 kept visits ($973 / $186). For four physicians that is 0.6 points off the no-show rate, inside the 0.5 to 3 points the two studies found. For one physician it is 2.4 points, toward the top of that range, so a solo office covers the program by running more than one tool on it: the agent's answered calls, reminders, recall, waitlist backfill and intake all run inside the same program10. Reminders alone, where a program is already in place, take 0.8 kept visits ($149 / $186). The missed-visit counts join a no-show rate from one hospital system and a worldwide review with appointment volumes from a third source, so they are a scale, not a forecast.
The $34.59 an hour in Table 6 is the Bureau of Labor Statistics figure for what employers pay, with benefits, for office and administrative support staff across health care and social assistance, a whole sector and not physician offices alone118.
The agent's own fee, $299 a month, is the cost of 8.6 front-desk hours a month ($299 / $34.59), or about 25 minutes a working day (8.6 x 60 minutes / 21 working days). The phone's whole talk time is ~20 to 34 hours a month (Call Box†'s 299 to 505 calls per office location28 x a four-minute call; likely low for a larger practice with more calls). The 8.6 hours are the fee in hours and not the talk time that covers it, because call minutes are billed: past the 250 included minutes an hour of calls costs $23.40 in usage (60 x $0.39) and releases $34.59. Counted on talk time alone, the agent covers its fee at about 18 hours of calls a month (1,080 minutes cost $622.70, $299 + 830 x $0.39, and release $622.62, 18 x $34.59). That is ~53% of all the talk time of the busier office (18 / 34) and ~90% of the quieter one (18 / 20), so hours alone are the weaker cover, though the work around a call, such as messages, callbacks and entries in the schedule, is not in the estimate.
A study that measures the hours an agent releases in a medical office is NF; the nearest evidence is Call Box†'s call counts above. Payment per visit is the 2016 primary care mean: what insurers and patients paid, not what the practice keeps. Chapter 5 shows the same counts at the median visit and at the 2023 mean.
Unanswered calls are a third gain. Each row of Table 7 multiplies cited links and leaves one open. Call Box† reports an average of 299 calls per office location in February 2020 and 505 in June 2020, among more than 1,700 US healthcare practices in a pandemic year28. Invoca† reports that 43% of calls answered by a person were leads and that 45% of those leads converted on the call27. The Invoca† source does not say whether a booked caller is a new or an existing patient, so a booking is valued at two ends: one primary care visit at $1869, and a new patient's first year at $300 (calc., above).
The open link is the share of missed callers that an agent turns into conversations. The ceiling on that share is ~86.4% (the share of its calls the Mount Sinai agent completed100; likely high, because that was a scripted outbound call to a patient who expected it). A field or randomized study of an agent answering inbound calls in a medical office is NF for the link itself; the nearest evidence is that outbound figure.
Table 7 therefore solves for the share the agent must hold to cover its own fee, $299 a month, at each end of a booking's value. At every share in the column for the agent's own fee, the calls the agent takes at four minutes each fit inside its 250 included minutes, so the fee is $299. Every one of those shares sits below the ceiling, and the highest, 33%, is below the 36.6% of Phase I calls that the Mount Sinai agent finished with no person100. Both figures are from outbound calls at one hospital, not from a front desk answering calls. The last column is the narrow case of a practice that buys the program for the agent alone and runs nothing else on it; there the smallest row needs more than all of the missed callers, which is above the ceiling.
| Share of calls reaching no one | Calls a month | Calls missed | Bookings lost if they convert like answered calls | Value, one visit each to a new patient each | Share of missed callers the agent must turn into conversations to cover its own fee ($299) | The same, if a program is bought for the agent alone (the narrow case, Table 5) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8.3% abandoned (VA call centers, 2016) | 299 | 25 | 4.8 | $893 to $1,441 | 21% to 33% | 78% to more than all of them |
| 8.3% abandoned (VA call centers, 2016) | 505 | 42 | 8.1 | $1,509 to $2,433 | 12% to 20% | 46% to 74% |
| 46%† not answered by a person (Invoca†, health care, 2026) | 299 | 138 | 26.6 | $4,950 to $7,985 | 4% to 6% | 14% to 23% |
| 46%† not answered by a person (Invoca†, health care, 2026) | 505 | 232 | 45.0 | $8,361 to $13,487 | 2% to 4% | 8% to 13% |
Table 7. The medical call chain (calc.): calls a month28 times the share reaching no one26,27 (the 46% is 100% less Invoca†'s 54% answered by a person), times 43% leads and 45% booked on the call27, times $186 for one visit at the low end and $300 for a new patient's first year at the high end. Each share is the fee ($299, the agent's published price with 250 call minutes included8) divided by that value: in the first row, $299 / $1,441 = 21% and $299 / $893 = 33%. The last column divides $1,123 ($299 + $824) by the same values: $1,123 / $1,441 = 78% and $1,123 / $893 = 126%, which is more than all of the missed callers.
The two miss rates are different measures from different settings and are not averaged. The chain is set against the agent's own fee because answered calls are the agent's gain. The last column is the narrow case; the program is a layer that the site assistant, texts to patients and the front-desk add-ons also run inside, and Table 6 sets its fee against kept visits. The lead and booking shares are Invoca†'s figures for answered calls, applied here to missed callers on the assumption that the two groups are alike, which the source does not show, and the chain counts none of the callers who call back. Front-desk hours, in Table 6, are a separate gain of the agent, on top of this one.
Four front-desk add-ons run on the same program: reminders and rebooking at $149 a month, recall and reactivation at $199, waitlist backfill at $99, and intake with insurance capture at $149 a month plus $250 setup, or $449 a month for all four, per location, plus usage10. They are bought for the same service, and this chapter claims no effect size for them beyond the reminder studies above. Reminders and rebooking act on the missed visits in Table 6, and waitlist backfill acts on the slots that a cancellation opens. Chapter 5 sets the whole system against the same inputs, and the full medical ledger is in our AI-profit paper.
What this chapter cannot establish
The published measures of unanswered calls come from VA call centers and from Invoca†, Call Box† and CallMyDoc†, not from private physician offices, so the ~8.3% to 46% we gave for such offices is built from them. The same holds for an AI agent: the effect on attendance, the share of inbound calls it finishes and the hours it releases are built from adjacent figures. The nearest evidence is outbound calls at one hospital and a telecommunications company's phone menu100,112.
A practice can close the first gap itself: a month of its own call log shows calls received, answered by a person, answered by an agent, abandoned and returned, and its schedule shows appointments offered and kept. Chapter 6 lists what to count and gives the published figures to read the counts against.
Chapter 5
AI in a medical practice: the AI medical receptionist, HIPAA and where AI pays
AI in healthcare marketing: what owners search for
Among the AI phrases in our keyword data that name HIPAA, medical or healthcare, the compliance phrase is the largest: hipaa compliant ai drew about 6,600 US searches a month in Google Ads keyword data for November 202632, against about 140 for ai medical receptionist and about 110 for ai in healthcare marketing. Table 1 gives the cost per click and adds two broader phrases.
| Search phrase | US searches a month | Cost per click |
|---|---|---|
| ai receptionist32 | 74,000 | $43.66 |
| ai answering service32 | 4,400 | $58.48 |
| hipaa compliant ai32 | 6,600 | $41.88 |
| ai medical receptionist32 | 140 | $80.76 |
| ai in healthcare marketing32 | 110 | $23.96 |
Table 1. Searches near the question of AI in a medical office, Google Ads keyword data, November 2026. The first two phrases are not specific to medicine.
A practice owner, an administrator or a vendor would type these phrases; a patient would not. Volume shows interest, not purchase, and cost per click is what advertisers pay, not what a patient or a tool is worth. The compliance phrase is searched about 47 times as often as the phrase for the role it would apply to (6,600 / 140). We think owners look for a rule before they look for a tool, though developers and vendors probably type it too, so it is not a count of practices asking.
We do not give any tool a compliance label, ours included. HHS says that no standard or implementation specification in the Security Rule requires a covered entity to certify its compliance7. It also says it does not endorse or otherwise recognize private organizations' certifications regarding the Security Rule, and that such certifications do not absolve covered entities of their legal obligations under that rule7. Both statements concern the Security Rule, not the whole of HIPAA. What we sell is HIPAA-ready: a compliance layer added to a plan, which does not include the AI voice agent10. Compliance depends on a signed business associate agreement and on how a tool is set up.
Chapter 2 covers how AI assistants name practices, and Chapter 4 the design of the phone.
What studies of AI at work show, and what they leave out for a medical office
In a study of 5,179 customer support agents, access to a generative AI conversational assistant raised productivity, measured as issues resolved per hour, by 14% on average119,120. The gain was 34% for novice and low-skilled workers, with minimal impact on experienced and highly skilled workers119. The authors also report that AI assistance improved customer sentiment and increased employee retention119. The tool assisted human support agents, so we infer that the study says nothing about an AI that answers customers on its own120.
Two experiments on professional tasks point the same way and add a warning. In a writing experiment, access to ChatGPT cut the time on a mid-level professional writing task by 10 minutes, or 37%, against a control-group average of 27 minutes121. It also compressed the productivity distribution by benefiting low-ability workers more121. In an experiment with consultants, tasks inside the technological frontier were completed 25.1% more quickly and produced results of more than 40% higher quality than a control group's122. For a task chosen to lie outside the frontier, consultants using AI were 19 percentage points less likely to produce correct solutions than those without AI122.
A fourth study asks whether such gains reach the wage bill. In an April 2025 working paper, Humlum and Vestergaard report that AI chatbots had no significant impact on earnings or recorded hours in any occupation, with confidence intervals ruling out effects larger than 1%123. The same paper reports modest productivity gains, with average time savings of 3%, and weak wage pass-through123. A later NBER version, retitled, rules out effects larger than 2% two years after the launch of ChatGPT124. We do not merge the two figures. For a practice, saved minutes are not saved dollars until someone decides what the minutes are for.
Two experiments touch the customer's side of the exchange. In a natural field experiment at a large telecommunications company, a voice-based AI system that replaced the phone menu (an interactive voice response system) temporarily increased machine-service duration and customers' demand for human service, but persistently reduced customer complaints112. In a 2026 preprint on a randomized field experiment on Alibaba's Taobao platform, deploying an agentic AI system for AI-eligible customer chats reduced average chat duration, had limited effects on retrial rates and substantially lowered ratings for those chats125.
None of these four studies is of a medical office. For medicine, three sources come closer, and each has a limit. The AMA's 2026 survey of 1,692 physicians, fielded January 15 to February 2, 2026, found that 81% reported awareness or use of AI in their practice, up from 66% in 2024126, and 19% reported no AI use126. The most common uses were summaries of medical research and standards of care (39%) and documentation of billing codes, charts or visit notes (28%), then draft replies to patient portal messages (19%)127. The survey measures awareness or use, not deployment, and its list of uses has no phone or front-desk use.
MGMA's polls ask practice leaders, and the pages do not describe how respondents were drawn. In a February 2026 poll of 177 responses on where leaders were turning to AI and automation to improve access, scheduling ranked first at 31% and calls second at 27%128. In an April 2025 poll of 375 responses, about one in five (19%) medical group practices used some version of a chatbot or virtual assistant for patient communication129. Neither counts deployed voice agents.
The third source is the one peer-reviewed study of an AI voice agent in a clinical setting that we found, and it concerns outbound calls. At Mount Sinai in 2025, an AI voice assistant making pre-procedure calls completed 86.4% of its calls in Phase I100. In Phase I, 36.6% of calls were fully automated and about a third needed a quick protocol-driven nurse callback100, and an AI hallucination led to an incomplete call in 6 calls, or 0.7%100. It was one cath lab with no randomized control group, and the calls were to scheduled patients, so it shows what a voice agent can finish and nothing about a front desk. A randomized or field study of an agent answering inbound calls or scheduling in a medical office is NF; the nearest evidence is the Mount Sinai study of outbound calls above. Chapter 4 gives our estimates from neighboring figures and the way each likely errs.
The figures above bound judgment and do not forecast a practice. Brynjolfsson, Rock and Syverson argue that general purpose technologies such as AI enable and require significant complementary investments, including co-invention of new processes, products, business models and human capital130. We think the complements in a medical office are plain: who handles a transfer, which questions go to a nurse and who reads the log. Those decisions cost staff time before the tool saves any.
HIPAA compliant AI: patient information, business associates and the proposed Security Rule
HHS describes a business associate as a person or organization that performs functions or activities on behalf of a covered entity that involve creating, receiving, maintaining or transmitting protected health information, or PHI101. Under HHS guidance a subcontractor that does the same on behalf of a business associate is itself a business associate101. A covered entity may disclose PHI to a business associate if it obtains satisfactory assurance that the associate will appropriately safeguard it102, and the assurance must be documented in a written contract or other written agreement that meets the requirements of 45 CFR 164.504(e)102. Whether a given AI tool is a business associate of a given practice is for counsel; we describe the texts and do not apply them.
If an agent's calls pass through more than one vendor, each vendor that handles PHI raises the subcontractor question. Our check of 28 software tools that small practices commonly use found that, according to the vendors' own pages, 9 will sign a business associate agreement without requiring a special tier, 15 sign one only on certain plans and 4 offer none69. The general-purpose assistants in the check, ChatGPT and Claude, are among the 15 plan-gated tools69. The question for a practice is therefore whether the account in use is covered by an agreement, which depends on the plan. Chapter 4 sets out what the agreement must contain, and our check of which tools sign a BAA lists the full results.
HHS has proposed changes to the Security Rule. In a notice of proposed rulemaking published January 6, 2025, HHS stated that electronic PHI, or ePHI, including ePHI in AI training data, prediction models and algorithm data that is maintained by a regulated entity for covered functions, is protected by the HIPAA Rules and all applicable standards and specifications131. The same proposal states that a regulated entity's risk analysis must include consideration of, among other things, the type and amount of ePHI accessed by the AI tool, to whom the data is disclosed, and to whom the output is provided131. Both statements come from a proposal, not from a final rule.
A Unified Agenda entry for the proposal, retrieved on November 10, 2026, lists the stage as Long-Term Actions and the final action as 07/00/2027132. A date on an agenda is a plan, not a commitment. We think the questions in the proposal are useful whatever happens to the text: what the tool can see, where the data goes and who receives the output.
The AI medical receptionist and the cost pressure on staff time
In MGMA's June 23, 2026 Stat poll, 84% of medical groups reported year-to-date operating costs higher than at the same point in 2025, and the poll had 251 applicable responses17. It polls respondents, not every practice. Over a longer span, MGMA's DataDive analysis reports that from 2011 to 2024 median total operating cost per full-time-equivalent physician rose 71.6% in physician-owned multispecialty groups and 83.3% in hospital- or IDS-owned peers, while the consumer price index rose 39.5%18. The comparison covers multispecialty groups, so a small single-specialty practice may look different.
Many physicians work in small practices. In the AMA's 2024 Physician Practice Benchmark Survey, 47.4% of physicians worked in practices with 10 or fewer physicians, compared with 61.4% in 201211. The AMA changed its survey vendor in 2024 and expanded the sample from 3500 to 5000 physicians, so the trend carries that caveat11. A small practice has few physicians over which to spread a front desk.
The right price for a released front-desk hour is what the employer pays for it, benefits included. For office and administrative support occupations within health care and social assistance, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reports employer compensation of $34.59 per hour worked in June 2026: $23.50 in wages and salaries and $11.08 in benefits118. The row covers the whole health care and social assistance sector and a broad occupation group, not offices of physicians alone. We use $34.59 an hour for a released hour118, and a practice should replace it with its own cost per hour.
An AI receptionist answers calls, books and reschedules, and hands off to the office team what it cannot handle. Our AI voice agent costs $299 a month with 250 call minutes included, then $0.39 a minute8. A medical office that wants its calls answered buys the agent inside a HIPAA-ready program, added to a plan; the plan alone needs no program10. Plans are $999, $1,999 and $2,999 a month for one location, and each additional location is $299 a month8. The two lower plans carry a one-time onboarding fee of $499 and $999, and the top plan a $3,000 setup fee. A 12-month term paid in full is two months free, at $9,990, $19,990 and $29,990 a year (a saving of $1,998, $3,998 and $5,998); a 12-month term also waives the two onboarding fees and cuts the setup fee to $1,4008. The Essentials program is $1,500 setup plus $699 a month per location after a compliance consultation10, and it does not include the agent10. Our page for medical offices describes the service, and Chapter 4 works through the monthly arithmetic.
Where AI pays in a medical practice
A practice buys a system: a plan that produces demand, an agent that answers it, and, for a medical practice, a HIPAA-ready program as the compliance layer for the tools that touch patient information. The paper on AI profit sets out a profit identity with four mechanisms: capture of contacts that would have been lost, conversion of contacts already answered, capacity released and retention. Its system ledger adds demand above them, and here the gains are counted five ways: demand, capture, kept appointments, staff hours released and retention. Each fee is set against the gain its own product produces: the plan against new patients, the agent against answered calls and hours, and the program against everything that runs on it (kept visits through the reminders add-on, and the other front-desk add-ons). A ledger for the agent alone would leave the plan out of both sides.
A practice can be short of appointments and still lose patients and visits it could have kept: a caller who gives up, a missed visit that leaves a slot empty, a patient who leaves. A full schedule changes the form of the gain and does not make demand worthless. More demand lets a busy practice fill canceled slots, choose better-paying work, raise its minimum fee and justify another provider. Table 2 sets out the inputs for a primary care practice.
| Input | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Payment per primary care office visit | $186 mean, 2016 | AHRQ MEPS9 |
| Payment per office visit to any medical doctor | $347 mean, 2023 | AHRQ MEPS37 |
| Office visits per person a year, all physicians | 3.21, 2019 | CDC NAMCS34 |
| Share of visits made to primary care | 50.3% | CDC NAMCS34 |
| New patients as a share of primary care visits | 12.5% | CDC NAMCS35 |
| Appointments per primary care physician | 51.1 a week, 2021 | Rotenstein et al., Epic data33 |
| No-show rate | 18.8% to 23% | Ten main clinics of one VA medical center2; review of 105 studies3 |
| Effect of reminder calls on no-shows in two studies | 0.5 to 3 points | Phone reminders at the same VA center, a before and after comparison2; live calls, one clinic, randomized38 |
| Years a patient stays with a physician | 8 median (patients 65 and over, one state) | Mold et al.36 |
| Front-office staff cost with benefits, health care | $34.59 an hour, June 2026 | BLS118 |
Table 2. Inputs for the primary care case, each as its source prints it. Payments are what all payers and the patient paid, as households reported them, not charges and not what a practice collects.
A person makes 1.61 primary care visits a year (3.21 x 50.3%), which is $300 a year at $186 a visit (3.21 x 50.3% x $186) and $2,400 over 8 years (8 x $300); that is an average over everyone, including people who made no visit, so a person who seeks a practice out is likely to bring more. One physician has 221 scheduled appointments a month (51.1 x 52 / 12), and four have 886 (4 x 51.1 x 52 / 12).
The $186 is a 2016 mean, and a mean is pulled up by expensive visits: the 2016 median for primary care was $1079. An added visit is worth the mean on average, but payments differ by payer: for most physician specialties in 2016, the median payment per visit was highest for persons with private insurance and lowest for persons on Medicaid9.
The NAMCS counts are from 2019, before the pandemic, and NAMCS defines primary care more broadly than the MEPS payment figure does. The 51.1 appointments come from health-system Epic data for January to May 2021 and are scheduled appointments, so kept visits are 171 to 180 a month for one physician once 18.8% to 23% are missed (calc., Table 3). The no-show rate and the 0.5-point reminder effect come from one VA medical center, and the 3-point effect from one randomized trial at one clinic. The missed-visit counts join a no-show rate from one hospital system and a worldwide review with appointment volumes from a third source, so they give a scale, not a forecast.
The 2018 systematic review of 105 studies puts the average no-show rate in healthcare appointment scheduling at about 23%, with a range from 13.2% in Oceania to 43.0% in Africa3, so a practice's own rate is the number that matters. Chapter 4 reviews what the studies found about reminders, and Chapter 6 shows how to count the rate.
Table 3 sets each fee against what it buys, for one physician and for four. The cost side uses our prices: the lowest plan at $999 a month8, the voice agent at $299 a month with 250 call minutes included8 and the Essentials program at $699 a month with $1,500 setup10. The included minutes are about 62 four-minute calls (250 / 4), $0.39 a minute applies after them, and every case in this chapter stays inside them, so the agent's fee is its published $299. Spreading the $1,500 setup over the first 12 months comes to $125 a month.
The agent, added to a plan the practice already has, then costs $299 a month. Essentials is the compliance layer that every tool handling patient information runs inside, and it does not include the agent10; it costs $824 a month in the first year ($699 + $125) and $699 after, and the site assistant, texts to patients and the front-desk add-ons share it10. The two come to $1,123 a month in the first year ($299 + $824), which is the narrow case of a practice that runs nothing else on the program. The lowest plan with the agent and Essentials costs $2,122 ($999 + $299 + $824), and after the first year the full stack costs $1,997 ($999 + $299 + $699). A more expensive plan adds the difference between plan prices. The program and the reminders add-on, $973 a month ($824 + $149), are set against kept visits, and the agent against front-desk hours. The whole stack is set against both gains.
| One physician | Four physicians | |
|---|---|---|
| Appointments a month | 221 | 886 |
| Kept visits a month, once 18.8% to 23% are missed | 171 to 180 | 682 to 719 |
| Payments a month at $186 a kept visit | $31,714 to $33,444 | $126,855 to $133,774 |
| New-patient visits a month now, at 12.5% of kept visits | 21 to 22 | 85 to 90 |
| Plan alone, $999 a month: new patients needed, first year only | 3.3 (15.6% more) | 3.3 (3.9% more) |
| The same, counting three years, and counting 8 years | 1.1 and 0.4 | 1.1 and 0.4 |
| Program and reminders, $973 a month: kept visits needed | 5.2 (2.4 points off the no-show rate) | 5.2 (0.6 points off) |
| Reminders alone, $149 a month, where the program is already in place: kept visits needed | 0.8 | 0.8 |
| What one point off the no-show rate is worth a month | $412 | $1,647 |
| Kept visits if no-shows fall by 0.5 to 3 points | 1.1 to 6.6 ($206 to $1,236) | 4.4 to 26.6 ($824 to $4,942) |
| Agent, $299 a month: the fee in front-desk hours, at $34.59 | 8.6 a month (about 25 minutes a working day) | 8.6 a month (about 25 minutes a working day) |
| Everything together, $2,122 a month: share of payments | 6.3% to 6.7% | 1.6% to 1.7% |
| Kept visits needed, as a share of the 42 to 51 and 167 to 204 missed | 22.4% to 27.4% | 5.6% to 6.9% |
| New patients needed instead, first year only | 7.1 (33.2% more) | 7.1 (8.3% more) |
| The same, counting three years, and counting 8 years | 2.4 and 0.9 | 2.4 and 0.9 |
Table 3. Each fee set against what it buys (calc. from the inputs in Table 2 and our prices). The program and the reminders add-on are set against kept visits, and the agent against front-desk hours. The first-year new-patient counts value a patient at one year of payments, and the multi-year counts at three and at 8 years. Payments and new-patient visits use kept visits and not scheduled appointments.
Unanswered calls are a separate gain, priced in Chapter 4 with the medical call chain. Table 7 in that chapter shows that, at 299 to 505 calls a month and the two published miss rates, the agent has to turn 2% or more of missed callers into conversations to cover its own $299 a month, depending on whether a booking is worth one visit or a new patient's first year. The highest share, 33%, is at the VA rate for an office with 299 calls a month when each booking is one visit (calc., Table 7 in Chapter 4). That chain is set against the agent's own fee, and Chapter 4 carries the cautions on its rates and on the lead and booking shares of Invoca† (call tracking).
Staff hours released are worth $692 at 20 hours, $1,384 at 40 hours and $2,767 at 80 hours a month at $34.59 (hours x $34.59). Hours count only if they go to a next best use or paid hours fall. Chapter 4 puts the phone's whole talk time at ~20 to 34 hours a month (from Call Box†'s 299 to 505 calls per office location x a four-minute call; likely low for a larger practice), which caps what the calls alone can release. A study that measures the hours an agent releases in a medical office is NF; the nearest evidence is those call counts.
For a solo primary care office the agent's own fee is $299 a month, the cost of 8.6 front-desk hours ($299 / $34.59) or of the answered calls in Chapter 4. The program is the larger fee: to cover the program and reminders by kept visits alone, a one-physician practice needs 2.4 points off its no-show rate, toward the top of the 0.5 to 3 points that the two studies found. The full stack needs 7.1 new patients a month counting only their first year, 33.2% more than the 21 to 22 new-patient visits a month a primary care physician has now. For a solo office the case therefore rests on combining the gains and on what else the compliance layer carries: reminders and rebooking, recall and reactivation, waitlist backfill and intake all run on it10. A four-physician practice covers the program and reminders with 0.6 points off its no-show rate, and the full stack is 1.6% to 1.7% of its payments, against 6.3% to 6.7% for one physician (calc., Table 3).
The payment per visit above is the 2016 primary care mean, and the 2023 mean across all doctor visits is $347, nearly twice that37. Table 4 shows the same counts at three payment levels, from the 2016 primary care median9 to the 2023 mean for any medical doctor37.
| Payment per visit | A patient's payments in a year | New patients a month to cover the plan | Kept visits a month to cover the program and reminders | Kept visits a month to cover everything |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Median primary care visit, 2016: $107 | $173 | 5.8 | 9.1 | 19.8 |
| Mean primary care visit, 2016 (used above): $186 | $300 | 3.3 | 5.2 | 11.4 |
| Mean visit to any medical doctor, 2023: $347 | $560 | 1.8 | 2.8 | 6.1 |
Table 4. The counts of Table 3 at three payment levels (calc.). The plan column counts a new patient's first year only.
The mean is the right figure for what a practice collects, because total payments are the number of visits times the mean. The 2023 mean includes expensive specialty visits and is not a primary care number, so it shows only how far the older primary care figure may sit from a practice's payments today. At the median, a solo physician needs 9.1 kept visits a month for the program and reminders, which is 4.1 points off the no-show rate (9.1 / 221) and above the 3 points in either study, and a four-physician practice needs 1.0 points (9.1 / 886).
Payments are not what the practice keeps after the cost of the visit. A kept visit in a slot that is already staffed adds nearly all of its payment, a new patient who needs added capacity adds less, and a practice should use its own margin.
The system loses money in one corner only: a practice that is not growing and whose intake and scheduling are already sufficiently optimized, with few missed calls, few missed visits, few patients leaving and little front-desk time to release. The cited base rates put a typical practice far from it. A no-show rate of 18.8% to 23% means 42 to 51 missed visits a month for one physician out of 221 appointments (221 x 18.8% and 221 x 23%)2,3. The two published measures of unanswered calls also sit well above zero: 8.3% abandoned in VA call centers in September 201626, and 46% not answered by a person (100% - the 54% answered that Invoca† reports for health care organizations)27. Neither is a private physician office. The corner is the exception, and a practice finds out how far it sits from it by counting, which Chapter 6 shows.
None of these tables prices an error. The margin that errors would have to consume is the gap between a gain and its cost: at four physicians, one point off the no-show rate is worth $1,647 a month against $973 for the program and reminders, a margin of $674 ($1,647 - $973). The section on what can go wrong describes errors without pricing them. For the full monthly ledger of a medical practice, with every input stated, see the paper's medical ledger.
We think the use likeliest to pay is one that can be counted in calls, visits or hours and that sits inside what the tool does well. Call answering, scheduling and backfilling a cancellation meet both tests: the calls and hours are in the phone log and the visits are in the schedule. Routine questions about hours, location and accepted insurance are bounded and checkable. Marketing copy is the weakest case, because nothing in the practice's own records counts what it did. A use that cannot be counted cannot be priced, and a use outside the tool's competence is where the consultant experiment above shows errors rising.
What can go wrong, and what it has cost others
The enforcement record we cite involves people replying to online reviews, not AI. We include it because we think an automated reply has the same failure at a larger scale: it says something about a patient that should not be said. Table 5 lists four actions that HHS's pages and agreements describe.
| Practice and date | Conduct as HHS describes it | Result |
|---|---|---|
| A Dallas dental practice, announced October 2, 2019 | A patient complained that its reply to her Yelp review disclosed her last name, details of her treatment plan, insurance and cost information80 | $10,000 and a corrective action plan79 |
| A dental practice, page last reviewed December 14, 2022 | A complaint that it habitually answered reviews with full names where patients used only Yelp monikers, and with detailed information about visits and insurance82 | $23,000 and a corrective action plan81 |
| A New Jersey psychiatric provider, page last reviewed June 5, 2023 | Disclosed the protected health information of four patients in response to their negative reviews on Google Reviews78 | $30,000 and a corrective action plan77 |
| A North Carolina dental practice, page last reviewed March 28, 2022 | Disclosed a patient's PHI on a webpage in response to a negative online review, did not respond to OCR's data request or an administrative subpoena, and waived its rights to a hearing83 | A $50,000 civil money penalty83 |
Table 5. HHS enforcement actions over replies to online reviews. As described, none involved an AI tool.
Chapter 3 sets out the penalty tiers HHS publishes. We expect the corrective action plans in the first three to cost a practice time and staff attention beyond the payment, and a reply drafted by AI and posted without review would repeat the pattern at machine speed. Our design position is that review replies stay with a person who knows the rules.
A documented failure of a health chatbot shows a different risk. CBS News reported that the National Eating Disorders Association said, after critics' complaints, that the current version of its Tessa chatbot may have given information that was harmful and unrelated to the program, and took the program down pending an investigation133. That is a news report of an organization's statement about an eating disorders association's chatbot, not a medical office's. It is one case and carries no rate. We think the design lesson is that a patient-facing bot's output has to be bounded by what the bot is for.
NIST names the hazards in general terms. It defines confabulation as the production of confidently stated but erroneous or false content134, and it lists data privacy among generative AI risks, including leakage and unauthorized use, disclosure, or de-anonymization of health and other sensitive information134. For a front-desk agent we infer the practical reading is a short list of actions it may take and a hard stop at anything else.
Patients may also dislike the idea. In a December 2023 Gartner survey of 5,728 customers, 64% said they would prefer that companies did not use AI in their customer service111, and 53% said they would consider switching to a competitor if they found out a company was going to use AI for customer service111. It is an analyst firm's survey of customers in general, not of patients. We estimate that the share of patients uncomfortable with an AI that answers the phone is below the 60% that Pew found uncomfortable with their provider relying on AI in their own health care135 (from Pew's 60%, since a phone call is not a diagnosis; likely high).
A Talker Research survey commissioned by PatientPoint† (point-of-care media) reports that 53% of 2,000 adults who had seen a doctor expected scheduling without speaking to a human to become standard practice in the near future136, an expectation, not a preference. An independent survey of patients about an AI receptionist is NF; the nearest evidence is the Pew, Gartner and PatientPoint† surveys above. The CFPB's June 2023 report said several customers had filed complaints with the CFPB about getting stuck in "doom loops" with chatbots137. Several complaints are not a rate. We think the lesson carries over: every path through the agent should end at a person. Chapter 4 covers telling a patient that they are speaking with an AI, and the recording laws.
What stays with a clinician
The list below is our design position for a front-desk agent, not clinical or legal advice; the practice's clinicians and counsel set the real line. Each item stays with a licensed person or the practice's own staff.
- Symptoms, urgency and triage: the agent does not assess a caller who describes symptoms, a reaction to a medication or an emergency. An emergency caller is told to dial 911, and an urgent concern on the practice's own list goes to the on-call person the practice named.
- Diagnosis, test results, treatment and medication advice, including any explanation of clinical findings.
- Decisions about who may be seen, in what order, and whether a visit type fits the problem, which clinicians set and the agent follows.
- Replies to reviews that mention a patient's care.
- Consent, billing disputes and any exception to the practice's policies.
- Review of the agent's logs and the decision to change what it may say.
Tasks outside what the tool does well are where results got worse in the consultant experiment122, and we think clinical questions are the tasks where a wrong answer costs the most. In one 2023 study of public patient questions, licensed health professionals preferred a chatbot's response to the verified physician's response in 78.6% of 585 evaluations3. That shows evaluators preferred the chatbot's text in that study; it does not show that a practice can let it answer its own patients.
California's section 1339.75 draws a line close to the one in the list. It excludes appointment scheduling, billing and other clerical or business matters from its definition of patient clinical information105, and its disclaimer requirements do not apply if a generative-AI communication is read and reviewed by a human licensed or certified health care provider105. Its split between clinical and administrative content is the split this list uses. Chapter 4 describes the text, and whether it reaches a given practice is for counsel.
Evidence on an agent at the front desk is thin, and this chapter and Chapter 4 rest on estimates from neighboring figures. What would settle it is a study that places an AI scheduling or voice agent in medical offices and reports the hours released, the visits kept, the calls handed to staff and the errors, against a comparison group. Until then a practice can count before and after, and keep the change that the count supports.
Chapter 6
Measuring medical practice marketing: ROI, call tracking and a first 90 days
Marketing ROI, call tracking and healthcare CRM: what owners search for
Among the phrases near this chapter's subject, those about measuring and tracking, such as call tracking, marketing roi and marketing attribution, are searched more often than those that name patient acquisition directly. Table 1 gives US searches a month and the average cost per click in Google Ads keyword data for November 2026.
| Search phrase | US searches a month | Cost per click |
|---|---|---|
| call tracking32 | 1,600 | $49.17 |
| marketing roi32 | 880 | $14.57 |
| healthcare crm32 | 720 | $42.99 |
| marketing attribution32 | 720 | $46.41 |
| patient engagement32 | 590 | $12.10 |
| patient acquisition32 | 170 | $36.38 |
| how to get more patients32 | 70 | $34.11 |
| hipaa compliant marketing32 | 40 | $26.65 |
| new patient marketing32 | 10 | none reported |
Table 1. Searches near the subject of measurement and patient acquisition, Google Ads keyword data, November 2026. Call tracking, marketing roi and marketing attribution are not specific to medicine.
A practice owner or a vendor would type these phrases, and few are what a patient types. Volume shows interest, not purchase, and cost per click is what advertisers pay for the phrase, not what a patient is worth. We think the gap between the two groups is owners shopping for tools and reports before they phrase the goal as winning patients. This paper does not measure what share of practices count anything at all.
Why advertising returns are hard to measure, even for large firms
Twenty-five large field experiments run by Lewis and Rao, with major US retailers and brokerages and most reaching millions of customers, reveal that measuring the returns to advertising is difficult138. The median confidence interval on return on investment across their experiments was over 100 percentage points wide138. Individual-level sales are very volatile relative to the per capita cost of advertising, a coefficient of variation of 10 being common, so informative experiments can easily require more than 10 million person-weeks, which makes experiments costly and potentially infeasible for many firms138. They also conclude that selection bias, due to the targeted nature of advertising, is "a crippling concern" for widely employed observational methods138.
Other large studies point the same way. Gordon and co-authors used 15 US advertising experiments at Facebook, comprising 500 million user-experiment observations and 1.6 billion ad impressions, to compare experimental results with observational methods139. They found that observational methods often fail to produce the same effects as randomized experiments, even after conditioning on extensive demographic and behavioral variables139. In eBay's paid search, Blake, Nosko and Tadelis report that typical OLS methods give a return on investment of over 4,100% without time and geographic controls, and over 1,400% with such controls140. Experimental methods gave a return of -63%, with a 95% confidence interval of -124% to -3%140.
The same eBay work shows where a naive count goes wrong. When brand-keyword paid search was turned off, 99.5% of the forgone click traffic was immediately captured by natural, unpaid search traffic from the platform140. For non-brand keywords, new and infrequent users were positively influenced by the ads, but more frequent users, whose purchasing was not influenced, accounted for most of the advertising expense, giving average returns that were negative140. Berman adds a theoretical point: in a game-theoretic model of multi-publisher advertising, last-touch attribution over-incentivizes ad exposures, often resulting in lower advertiser profits141.
None of these studies is of a medical practice, and the practice cannot run a 10-million-person-week experiment. We think three lessons transfer. A number that an advertising platform reports for itself is not an experiment. A comparison of people who saw an ad with people who did not can be biased by who was targeted. And a patient who searches for the practice by name may already be on the way, so a report that credits an ad for that visit, or for every visit that follows a click, may be counting visits that were coming anyway. The cheap version of an experiment is to change one thing at a time and keep the same counts before and after; this paper does not measure how much that recovers. The long paper on professional practices treats measurement and attribution for a small practice in depth.
Measuring inside HIPAA: tags, analytics and the tools that offer no agreement
Chapter 3 sets out the HHS tracking bulletin, the court decision that vacated part of it and the FTC actions; here we take only what measurement needs. HHS gives the example that if a patient makes an appointment through a covered clinic's website and the site uses third-party tracking technologies that send the appointment and the IP address to a vendor, the vendor is a business associate and a BAA is required6. In our check of vendors' own pages, four tools offer no business associate agreement: Zapier, Calendly, Google Analytics and Meta Pixel69. We set the two statements side by side and leave their combination to the practice's counsel or privacy officer.
The court's decision narrowed the bulletin without removing it. HHS's bulletin page states that in American Hospital Association v. Becerra the court vacated the guidance only to the extent it provided that HIPAA obligations are triggered where an online technology connects an individual's IP address with a visit to an unauthenticated public webpage addressing specific health conditions or healthcare providers6,68. The court's footnote says the vacatur is not intended to limit the legal operability of other guidance in the same HHS document68. HHS's bulletin also says that tracking technologies on many unauthenticated webpages do not have access to PHI, so their use is not regulated by the HIPAA Rules, though in some cases they may have access to PHI6. Which pages sit on which side is left open.
Several of the 15 tools in our check that sign a business associate agreement only on certain plans are of the kind a practice would use for counting and follow-up: CallRail, HubSpot, GoHighLevel, Acuity Scheduling, Jotform and Typeform are in the group69. Six of the 15 do not publish the price of the plan that qualifies69. Before buying a tool to count with, a practice has to find out which plan carries the agreement and what it costs, and for some tools it has to ask. Our check of which tools sign a BAA lists the results.
A healthcare CRM also holds a list of patients. HHS's marketing guidance says covered entities may not sell lists of patients or enrollees to third parties without obtaining authorization from each person on the list66. Whether sending a list to an advertising platform for audience matching falls under that sentence is a question for counsel. A measurement design of this kind sends no list at all.
The first-principles answer is to count where the practice already has the data. The criteria below are design choices, not legal conclusions:
- Count events in the practice's own systems, which are the phone log, the scheduling system and the front-desk tally, before adding any tag.
- Report by source category and week, never by person.
- Put no patient identifier, appointment detail or form content in a web address, a tag or an advertising audience.
- Where a tool outside the practice sees any of the above, ask the privacy officer whether an agreement is needed and whether the tool offers one on the plan in use.
- Keep a list of every tool that touches the website, the phone and scheduling, with the date of its agreement.
What a practice can count without statistics
Counting without statistics means counting what the practice already records, over periods long enough that a few events do not move the number, and reading the result as a change from a baseline. Table 2 lists eight counts, where each lives and what it cannot show.
| Count | Where it lives | What it shows | What it cannot show |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calls by source: search, listing, referral, other | Phone log, plus one question at booking | Which routes bring calls | Whether the caller became a patient |
| Calls answered, missed and returned | Phone system log | How often someone reached the caller | Why the caller rang |
| New-patient requests, appointments offered, booked and kept | Scheduling system | Where requests are lost between the ask and the visit | Why a request was lost |
| Appointments offered, by payer | Scheduling system, by insurance category | Whom the schedule is open to | Whom the practice ought to see, which is a policy choice |
| Days to the next open new-patient appointment | The schedule, read on the same weekday each week | How long a new patient waits | The wait of any one patient |
| Time to first response on web requests | Timestamps on the request and the reply | Speed of response | Quality of the reply |
| Cancellations filled | The schedule | Slots recovered | Whether the filled slot was a new patient or an existing one |
| Review requests sent, reviews received, replies sent | The review platform and a practice log | Whether asking works and what patients write | Whether reviews changed any choice |
Table 2. Eight counts a practice can keep without statistics.
From the first month, the phone log and the schedule give most of those counts, each with a definition you fix before you start and keep. From the phone log take calls received, the calls that rang off before anyone answered, and the mean seconds from ring to a person. From the schedule take appointments scheduled and the share not kept, and the days to the next open new-patient appointment. The VA counted abandonment as calls ended by the caller before a staff member answered26. Its mean abandonment rate was 12.0% in October 2014 and 8.3% in September 2016, and its mean speed of answer fell from 87 to 69 seconds26, against a goal of 30 seconds and 5%26. These are reference points for your own count, not targets for a private office. The 54% of calls answered by a person that Invoca† (call tracking) reports is a different measure, and we do not set it beside the VA rate27.
At the call volumes in Call Box†'s data, 299 to 505 a month per location, a month of the log is enough for a first reading of a rate28. The log also lets you solve for the open link in Chapter 4's call chain, the share of missed callers that an agent turns into conversations, which nobody has measured. Your log supplies the other input, your own missed calls a month, and Table 7 in Chapter 4 shows the share the agent must hold to cover its cost at 25 to 232 missed calls a month. For the schedule, the no-show rate is appointments not kept divided by appointments scheduled. The published rates to read yours against are a mean of 18.8% across the 10 main clinics of one VA medical center2 and about 23% in a review of 105 studies3, and Chapter 4's Table 6 gives the kept visits a month that cover the program and reminders, and the front-desk hours that cover the agent.
The days a new patient waits for the next open appointment is the practice's own measure of access and, we think, the one that shows whether access is what limits the practice. A 2025 survey by AMN Healthcare, from calls to 1,391 offices1, found an average new-patient wait of 31 days across six specialties in 15 large US metro areas1. The wait to see a family medicine physician averaged 23.5 days1. These are reference points for your own number, not benchmarks, because the practice's specialty, city and season differ. If the number is long and calls are rarely missed, we expect the gain from more demand to take another form: choosing which patients the open appointments go to, or adding a provider.
A telephone audit already uses offered appointments by payer as a count. In a simulated-patient telephone study of primary care practices in 10 states between November 2012 and April 2013, 84.7% of privately insured callers and 57.9% of Medicaid callers received a new-patient appointment24. A practice can count the same thing for its own callers: of those who ask for a new-patient appointment, what share is offered one, by payer. The count shows whom the schedule is open to; whom the practice should see stays with the owner.
Oldroyd and co-authors, as quoted from their Harvard Business Review article in a 2011 news report, audited 2,241 US companies by measuring how long each took to respond to a web-generated test lead142. In the same report 37% of the companies responded within an hour and 23% never responded at all142. The companies were not medical practices, and this paper does not measure how fast medical offices answer web requests. We cite the audit for the shape of the measure: response time needs only a timestamp on the request and one on the reply.
Reviews are the count with rules attached. In a 2012 national survey of the US public, among those who sought online physician ratings in the past year, 35% reported selecting a physician based on good ratings and 37% had avoided a physician with bad ratings19. The FTC's rule on consumer reviews, effective October 21, 2024, makes it an unfair or deceptive act for a business to provide compensation or other incentives in exchange for reviews expressing a particular sentiment84,87. On replies, HHS's page says a New Jersey psychiatric provider paid $30,000 and agreed to a corrective action plan over a response to a patient's negative online review77. Chapter 3 covers both texts. The count is requests sent and reviews received, and the replies are written by a person.
Patient value and retention, on cited figures
Gupta, Lehmann and Stuart define the value of a customer as the expected sum of discounted future earnings143. Valuing five firms from public data, they found that a 1% improvement in retention, margin or acquisition cost improves firm value by 5%, 1% and 0.1% respectively143. That comes from a model fitted to five firms, and the 5% depends on its assumptions. Reichheld and Sasser's 1990 Harvard Business Review article, in a summary republished by Bain & Company, states that companies can boost profits by almost 100% by retaining just 5% more of their customers144. We report it as the authors' statement (secondary) and rest nothing on it.
A person makes 1.61 primary care visits a year (3.21 physician office visits per person a year34 x the 50.3% of those visits made to primary care34). At the 2016 mean payment of $186 a primary care visit9 that is $300 a year (1.61 x $186, rounded). That is an average over everyone, including people who made no visit, so a person who seeks a practice out is likely to bring more. Payments are what insurers and patients paid, not what the practice keeps, so the figure is revenue, not profit. Chapter 5 shows the counts at the 2016 median visit and at the 2023 mean for any doctor visit as well. How long a patient stays is measured in one study: among 799 patients aged 65 and over of 23 primary care physicians in Oklahoma, with data from 1999 to 2000, the median relationship lasted 8 years and the mean 10.27 years36. At $300 a year, 8 years is $2,400 (8 x $300).
The study says nothing about working-age patients or about leaving over phone access. Of the 114 patients, 14%, who changed physician in its first year36, 87% changed involuntarily, 44% for insurance reasons and 40% because their doctor had moved, retired or died36. The 13% who changed by choice (100% - 87%) were about 15 patients (13% x 114), under 2% of the 799 (15 / 799). For these patients the pool a practice could protect through retention is small.
If a share r of patients return each year, a patient is expected to stay 1 divided by (1 minus r) years, and the payments over that stay are $300 times that (calc., Table 3). The table gives the result at three yearly retention rates. The rates are a range for the one link nobody has measured for working-age patients. The table does not discount later years, which would lower every figure; a practice picks its own rate. The study's mean stay of 10.27 years is close to the 10 years that a steady 90% yearly retention would give (calc., Table 3), so the 90% row is the one nearest the only measured figure.
| Yearly retention | Expected years a patient stays | Payments over that stay at $300 a year |
|---|---|---|
| 80% | 5.0 | $1,500 |
| 85% | 6.7 | $2,000 |
| 90% | 10.0 | $3,000 |
Table 3. Expected stay and payments at three yearly retention rates (calc. from $300 a year in payments9). The rates are a range for an unmeasured link, and later years are not discounted.
Raising retention from 85% to 90% adds $1,000 in payments per patient ($3,000 - $2,000, Table 3), and no acquisition cost enters, because a patient who stays is not won again. The table shows what a kept patient is worth, not how many patients a faster answer keeps. To cover the agent's own fee, $3,588 over a year (12 x $299 a month), the practice has to keep 12.0 patients for a year, counting one year of payments each ($3,588 / $300), or 1.5 patients counting the 8-year median stay of $2,400 each ($3,588 / $2,400).
The pool a phone could protect starts from one physician's 171 to 180 kept visits a month (calc. from 51.1 appointments a week in Epic data33, once 18.8% to 23% are missed). That is 2,052 to 2,160 a year (12 x 171 to 12 x 180), or ~1,300 patients at 1.61 visits per patient (2,052 to 2,160 / 1.61). Under 2% of them leaving by choice is fewer than ~26 patients a year (2% x 1,300; errors pull both ways), or ~105 for four physicians (calc.). On that estimate 1.5 kept patients are ~6% of one physician's voluntary leavers and ~1% of four physicians' leavers (calc., 1.5 / 26 and 1.5 / 105), while 12.0 is ~46% of one physician's pool and ~11% of four physicians' (calc., 12.0 / 26 and 12.0 / 105).
The estimate stacks a national visit rate onto a kept-visit count and an older-patient departure rate. It likely errs high on the panel, because the 1.61 visits is an average over everyone, including people who made no visit, and patients who use a practice visit more often, and low on departures among working-age patients. A measurement of patients leaving a practice over phone access is NF; the nearest evidence is the one Oklahoma study of why patients aged 65 and over changed physician36.
The numbers do not make retention the better lever. The measured pools are the missed visit and the missed call: 42 to 51 missed visits a month for one physician, and the missed-call rates in Chapter 4. The pool for retention is estimated, is small for one physician, and rests on the least evidence. Retention here means the share of last year's patients who were seen again this year, a count a scheduling system can produce. Read it with the reasons for leaving noted where they are known, since in the one study most changes came from insurance or a doctor who moved, retired or died.
A first 90 days, in order
We think the order below is the right one, and none of the steps requires our service.
Days 1 to 14: profile and listings
Claim and check your business profile and the listings that carry your name, address, phone number, hours and accepted insurance, and make them match. Chapter 2 covers what Google says about local ranking and what a practice controls. Start the tally now: calls answered and missed, new-patient requests, and the days to the next open new-patient appointment, read on the same weekday each week. Keep the tally for two weeks before you change the pages or the phone, so that later changes have something to be measured against.
Days 15 to 40: pages for each service, insurer and location
Write or repair one page for each service, each insurer you accept and each location, and a page for each physician. State the facts a patient needs: what the visit is, who sees you, what you accept and how to book. Make no promise of results. AMA Opinion 9.6.1 says there are no restrictions on advertising by physicians except those that can be specifically justified to protect the public from deceptive practices92. It is an ethics opinion, not law, and the compliance lead approves each page.
Days 41 to 60: the phone
Read the log you have kept. Decide who answers at which hours: staff, an answering service or an AI agent. Chapter 4 describes an answering design and the disclosure and recording texts, and Chapter 5 prices the choice on cited inputs. The long paper's chapter on the front desk, response and access treats it in depth. If the number of missed calls is small and the wait for an appointment is long, we think the phone is not where your money is. If missed calls are many, the log tells you at which hours.
Days 61 to 80: review requests inside the rules
Ask every patient the same way, with no reward tied to what they write, and keep the log of requests sent and reviews received. Write each reply yourself, or have a person who knows the rules write it, and put no patient detail in it. The FTC rule also covers suppression: under 16 CFR 465.7 it is a violation to use an unfounded or groundless legal threat, a physical threat, intimidation, or a knowingly false public accusation in response to a consumer review in an attempt to prevent it being written or to have it removed88. Whether a given request program stays within the text is for counsel.
Days 81 to 90: the count
Take the first monthly reading from the counts in Table 2 and compare each with the baseline from days 1 to 14. Pick one change to make next, and write down the count that would show whether it worked. Resist changing three things at once: with one change and one count you can read the result, which is the small-scale version of the experiments described earlier in this chapter.
Our prices as one reference point
Our plans are $999, $1,999 and $2,999 a month for one location, and each additional location is $299 a month8. The two lower plans carry a one-time onboarding fee of $499 and $999, and the top plan a $3,000 setup fee. A 12-month term paid in full is two months free, at $9,990, $19,990 and $29,990 a year (a saving of $1,998, $3,998 and $5,998); a 12-month term also waives the two onboarding fees and cuts the setup fee to $1,4008. A plan alone is marketing, carries no patient information and needs no HIPAA program10, so the lowest plan, $999 a month, is the least a medical practice can buy. The AI voice agent is $299 a month with 250 call minutes included, then $0.39 a minute8. It runs on patient calls, so it sits inside a HIPAA-ready program. The Essentials program is $1,500 setup plus $699 a month per location after a compliance consultation10, and it is a compliance layer added to a plan that does not include the agent10. The site assistant, texts to patients and the front-desk add-ons run inside the same layer10.
The agent's 250 included minutes are about 62 four-minute calls (250 / 4), and the worked cases in Chapter 4 stay inside them, so the agent, added to a plan the practice already has, costs its published $299 a month. With the setup spread over 12 months, Essentials costs $824 a month in the first year ($699 + $1,500 / 12) and $699 after. The two come to $1,123 a month in the first year ($299 + $824), the narrow case of a practice that runs nothing else on the program, and the lowest plan, agent and Essentials together cost $2,122 ($999 + $299 + $824). Chapter 4 sets the agent against front-desk hours and unanswered calls, and the program and the reminders add-on against kept visits. Managed marketing is a separate add-on at $1,800 a month on every term8. Our pricing page holds the current terms.
Limits of this paper and what would settle them
The first limit is the missing physician row. Our study of AI answers asked about chiropractors and med spas in 16 cities and about physical therapists in 3, a small sample45. It did not ask about physicians. Each question was asked once, names were matched across assistants by spelling, up to eight names were read per answer, and answers through an API are a baseline, not what every signed-in user sees45. The same questions asked about physicians, in the same cities, more than once, would settle it. Chapter 2 sets out what the study does show.
The evidence on how patients choose is older and narrower than a reader might wish. The survey of physician rating sites is from September 2012, a survey of the US public in which 65% of adults were aware of online physician ratings4. The published measures of unanswered calls are from VA call centers and from Invoca†, Call Box† and CallMyDoc†, and none is from a private physician office; the figures for payments and new patients are national surveys from 2016 and 2019; and the one study of how long patients stay is of patients aged 65 and over in one state, about 2000. The examples in this chapter and in Chapters 4 and 5 rest on those figures with those limits, and they solve for the one link no source measures, the share of missed callers that an agent turns into conversations.
The studies of advertising measurement come from large firms, and the retention work from a model of five firms and a secondary summary. The legal texts are described, not applied: the Security Rule text on AI that Chapter 5 describes is a proposal132, the AMA opinion cited above is an ethics opinion and not law, and state law, which Chapter 3 covers, is outside what this chapter describes. What would settle most of these is a measurement that none of our sources made: an audit of how private physician offices handle incoming calls, and practices willing to share their own counts, before and after one change, in a form that names no patient.
References
Before the paper cited a source, the page was fetched and the passage we rely on was matched against it, except where a reference is marked otherwise. The small numbers in the text point here.
- AMN Healthcare (formerly Merritt Hawkins). 2025 Survey of Physician Appointment Wait Times and Medicare and Medicaid Acceptance Rates. AMN Healthcare, 2025. amnhealthcare.com/siteassets/amn-insights/physician/ps-2025-physician-
- Parviz Kheirkhah, Qianmei Feng, Lauren M Travis, Shahriar Tavakoli-Tabasi, Amir Sharafkhaneh. Prevalence, predictors and economic consequences of no-shows. BMC Health Services Research, 1997-2008. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4714455/
- Dantas LF, Fleck JL, Cyrino Oliveira FL, Hamacher S. No-shows in appointment scheduling - a systematic literature review. Health Policy (abstract via Europe PMC), 2018. ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/search?query=EXT_ID:29482948%20AN
- David A. Hanauer; Kai Zheng; Dianne C. Singer; Achamyeleh Gebremariam; Matthew M. Davis. Public Awareness, Perception, and Use of Online Physician Rating Sites. JAMA, 2012-09. doi.org/10.1001/jama.2013.283194
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. 45 CFR 164.508 (Code of Federal Regulations, current text as reproduced by Cornell LII). Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (copy of the CFR), 2024. law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/164.508
- HHS Office for Civil Rights. Use of Online Tracking Technologies by HIPAA Covered Entities and Business Associates. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2024-06-20. hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance/hipaa-online-tracking
- HHS Office for Civil Rights. Are we required to “certify” our organization’s compliance with the standards of the Security Rule?. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2013-07-26. hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/faq/are-we-required-to-certify-our-org
- Technical Marketing. Pricing. Technical Marketing, 2026-11. technicalmarketing.ai/pricing/ Our own data.
- Steven R. Machlin and Emily M. Mitchell. Statistical Brief #517: Expenses for Office-Based Physician Visits by Specialty and Insurance Type, 2016. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (MEPS), 2016. meps.ahrq.gov/data_files/publications/st517/stat517.shtml
- Technical Marketing. HIPAA-ready programs. Technical Marketing, 2026-11. technicalmarketing.ai/hipaa/ Our own data.
- American Medical Association (Policy Research Perspectives). Physician Practice Characteristics in 2024: Private Practices Account for Less Than Half of Physicians in Most Specialties. American Medical Association, 2012. ama-assn.org/system/files/2024-prp-pp-characteristics.pdf
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. QCEW open data: 2024 annual averages, NAICS 6211 Offices of physicians (all areas). U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2024. data.bls.gov/cew/data/api/2024/a/industry/6211.csv
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Occupational Outlook Handbook: Physicians and Surgeons. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2025. bls.gov/ooh/healthcare/physicians-and-surgeons.htm
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. QCEW open data: 2024 first quarter, NAICS 6211 Offices of physicians (all areas). U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2024-Q1. data.bls.gov/cew/data/api/2024/1/industry/6211.csv
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. QCEW open data: 2024 first quarter by establishment size class 1, all industries and areas. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2024-Q1. data.bls.gov/cew/data/api/2024/1/size/1.csv
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. QCEW open data: 2024 first quarter by establishment size class 2, all industries and areas. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2024-Q1. data.bls.gov/cew/data/api/2024/1/size/2.csv
- Chris Harrop, MGMA. Operating costs keep climbing for medical practices in 2026 (MGMA Stat). Medical Group Management Association, 2026-06-23. mgma.com/mgma-stat/operating-costs-keep-climbing-for-medical-practices
- MGMA. Does your margin have breathing room? Insights from MGMA DataDive benchmarks (MGMA Stat). Medical Group Management Association, 2011-2024. mgma.com/mgma-stat/does-your-margin-have-breathing-room-mgma-stat-data
- Hanauer DA, Zheng K, Singer DC, Gebremariam A, Davis MM. Public Awareness, Perception, and Use of Online Physician Rating Sites. JAMA 2014;311(7):734-735 (author-hosted PDF), 2012. hai.ics.uci.edu/papers/jld130043.pdf
- Susannah Fox and Maeve Duggan. Health Online 2013. Pew Research Center, 2012. pewresearch.org/internet/2013/01/15/health-online-2013/
- Press Ganey. High standards, high stakes: How healthcare provider reviews drive patient choice. Press Ganey, 2023. pressganey.com/?p=19081 Secondary source.
- MSDC Staff. Report: Digital Medical Experience For Patients a Major Determinant in Booking an Appointment. Medical Society of the District of Columbia, 2021. msdc.org/detail/news/2021/12/08/report-digital-medical-experience-for- Secondary source.
- Adam E. Block, Medha Reddy and Ella Corkum. The Impact of 1-Star Physician Ratings on New Patient Volume. The American Journal of Managed Care, 2015-01-01 to 2018-04-25. ajmc.com/view/the-impact-of-1-star-physician-ratings-on-new-patient-vo
- Karin V. Rhodes; Genevieve M. Kenney; Ari B. Friedman; Brendan Saloner; Charlotte C. Lawson; Daniel Chearo; Douglas Wissoker; Daniel Polsky. Primary care access for new patients on the eve of health care reform. JAMA Internal Medicine, 2012-11/2013-04. doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2014.20
- Bisgaier. Auditing Access to Specialty Care for Children with Public Insurance. Massachusetts Medical Society, 2011. doi.org/10.1056/NEJMsa1013285
- Kevin N Griffith et al.. Call Center Performance Affects Patient Perceptions of Access and Satisfaction. American Journal of Managed Care, 2014-10. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8177735/
- Invoca. The Healthcare Lead Conversion Benchmarks Report 2026. Invoca, 2026. invoca.com/reports/the-invoca-healthcare-lead-conversion-benchmarks-re Secondary source.
- Call Box. The Top 5 Phone Trends of 2020 and How Healthcare Practices Are Taking Action: Data Study. Call Box, 2019-2020. assets-cdn.carwars.com/websites/callbox/resources/dental/CB+Healthcare Secondary source.
- Christi Crane (Ohio State News), on research led by Simon Haeder and Wendy Xu. Having insurance doesn't mean you can get a mental health appointment. The Ohio State University, 2025-10 to 2026-03. news.osu.edu/having-insurance-doesnt-mean-you-can-get-a-mental-health-
- George A. Akerlof. The Market for "Lemons": Quality Uncertainty and the Market Mechanism. The Quarterly Journal of Economics (Oxford University Press), 1970. doi.org/10.2307/1879431
- Uwe Dulleck; Rudolf Kerschbamer. On Doctors, Mechanics, and Computer Specialists: The Economics of Credence Goods. Journal of Economic Literature (American Economic Association), 2006. doi.org/10.1257/002205106776162717
- Technical Marketing. What service businesses search for: 2026 demand data. Technical Marketing, 2026-11. technicalmarketing.ai/reports/service-business-search-demand/ Our own data.
- Lisa S Rotenstein, Nate Apathy, Susan Edgman-Levitan, Bruce Landon. Comparison of Work Patterns Between Physicians and Advanced Practice Practitioners in Primary Care and Specialty Practice Settings. JAMA Network Open, 2021. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10265293/
- National Center for Health Statistics. FastStats - Ambulatory Care Use and Physician office visits. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2019. cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/physician-visits.htm
- Santo L, Kang K. National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2019 National Summary Tables. National Center for Health Statistics, 2019. stacks.cdc.gov/view/cdc/123251/cdc_123251_DS1.pdf
- James W. Mold, George E. Fryer, A. Michelle Roberts. When Do Older Patients Change Primary Care Physicians?. Journal of the American Board of Family Practice, 1999-2001. jabfm.org/content/17/6/453.long
- Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Center for Financing, Access, and Cost Trends. MEPS HC-248G: 2023 Office-Based Medical Provider Visits. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (MEPS), 2023. meps.ahrq.gov/data_stats/download_data/pufs/h248g/h248gdoc.shtml
- Tarabichi Y, Higginbotham J, Riley N, Kaelber DC, Watts B. Reducing Disparities in No Show Rates Using Predictive Model-Driven Live Appointment Reminders for At-Risk Patients: a Randomized Controlled Quality Improvement Initiative. Journal of General Internal Medicine (PMC10150669), 2022. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10150669
- Google. Tips to improve your local ranking on Google (Google Business Profile Help). Google Business Profile Help, 2026-11. support.google.com/business/answer/7091?hl=en
- Anindya Ghose, Avi Goldfarb, and Sang Pil Han. How Is the Mobile Internet Different? Search Costs and Local Activities. Information Systems Research / INFORMS, 2013. doi.org/10.1287/isre.1120.0453
- Johannes Beus. Why (almost) everything you knew about Google CTR is no longer valid. SISTRIX, 2020. sistrix.com/blog/why-almost-everything-you-knew-about-google-ctr-is-no Secondary source.
- Brian Dean. Here's What We Learned About Organic Click-Through Rate. Backlinko, 2023. backlinko.com/google-ctr-stats Secondary source.
- Google Search Central. AI features and your website. Google, 2025. developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/ai-features
- Google Search Central. Google Search's AI Overviews and Your Website. Google, 2024. developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/ai-overviews
- Technical Marketing. Who AI recommends locally: a study of local answers. Technical Marketing, 2026-11. technicalmarketing.ai/reports/ai-local-recommendations/ Our own data.
- Pew Research Center. Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears in the results. Pew Research Center, 2025-03. pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/07/22/google-users-are-less-likely-to
- Conductor. Health Care Industry: 2026 AEO / GEO Benchmarks. Conductor, 2025. conductor.com/academy/health-care-aeo-geo-benchmarks Secondary source.
- SE Ranking. AI Overviews Research: Analyzing Google's approach to YMYL topics. SE Ranking, 2024. seranking.com/blog/ai-overviews-and-ymyl-topics-research/ Secondary source.
- Miriam Ellis. New Research: The Prevalence of AI Overviews in Local Search. Whitespark, 2025. whitespark.ca/blog/case-study-the-prevalence-of-ai-overviews-in-local- Secondary source.
- Pew Research Center. Americans and AI 2026: Chatbots, Smart Devices and Views on Impact. Pew Research Center, 2026. pewresearch.org/internet/2026/06/17/americans-and-ai-2026-chatbots-sma
- Pew Research Center. From Diagnoses to Treatments, Why Americans Use AI Chatbots for Health. Pew Research Center, 2026. pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2026/08/PS_2026.8.25_AI-ch
- KFF. Poll: 1 in 3 Adults Are Turning to AI Chatbots for Health Information, Equaling the Share Who Use Social Media for Health. KFF, 2026. kff.org/health-information-trust/poll-1-in-3-adults-are-turning-to-ai-
- Rand Fishkin. 2024 Zero-Click Search Study: For every 1,000 EU Google Searches, only 374 clicks go to the Open Web. In the US, it's 360.. SparkToro, 2024. sparktoro.com/blog/2024-zero-click-search-study-for-every-1000-us-goog Secondary source.
- BrightLocal Research Team. Local Consumer Review Survey 2025. BrightLocal, 2025. brightlocal.com/research/local-consumer-review-survey-2025 Secondary source.
- Rosie Murphy. Local Consumer Review Survey 2026: Star Ratings Keep Rising, Old Reviews Don't Cut It. BrightLocal, 2026. brightlocal.com/research/local-consumer-review-survey/ Secondary source.
- Chatterji et al.. How People Use ChatGPT. National Bureau of Economic Research, 2025. doi.org/10.3386/w34255
- Rand Fishkin. NEW Research: AIs are highly inconsistent when recommending brands or products; marketers should take care when tracking AI visibility. SparkToro, 2025. sparktoro.com/blog/new-research-ais-are-highly-inconsistent-when-recom Secondary source.
- Liu, Zhang, and Liang. Evaluating Verifiability in Generative Search Engines. Association for Computational Linguistics, 2023. arxiv.org/abs/2304.09848
- Kung et al.. Performance of ChatGPT on USMLE: Potential for AI-assisted medical education using large language models. PLOS Digital Health, 2023. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pdig.0000198
- Andrew M. Bean et al.. Reliability of LLMs as medical assistants for the general public: a randomized preregistered study. Nature Medicine, 2026. nature.com/articles/s41591-025-04074-y
- Pranjal Aggarwal, Vishvak Murahari, Tanmay Rajpurohit, Ashwin Kalyan, Karthik Narasimhan, Ameet Deshpande. GEO: Generative Engine Optimization. arXiv, 2023. arxiv.org/abs/2311.09735
- Gao, McCullough, Agarwal, Jha. A Changing Landscape of Physician Quality Reporting: Analysis of Patients’ Online Ratings of Their Physicians Over a 5-Year Period. JMIR Publications Inc., 2012. doi.org/10.2196/jmir.2003
- Luca. Reviews, Reputation, and Revenue: The Case of Yelp.Com. Elsevier BV, 2016. doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1928601
- BrightLocal. Local Consumer Review Survey 2024. BrightLocal, 2024. brightlocal.com/research/local-consumer-review-survey-2024/ Secondary source.
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. 45 CFR 164.501 (Code of Federal Regulations, current text as reproduced by Cornell LII). Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (copy of the CFR), 2024. law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/164.501
- HHS Office for Civil Rights. Marketing (HIPAA Privacy Rule guidance). U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2026-11-10. hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance/marketing/index.html
- HHS Office for Civil Rights. Use of Online Tracking Technologies by HIPAA Covered Entities and Business Associates (archived copy, January 2023). Internet Archive copy of hhs.gov, 2022-12-01. web.archive.org/web/20230115000000/https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-profe
- United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas. American Hospital Association v. Becerra, No. 4:23-cv-01110-P (N.D. Tex.), Opinion and Order, ECF No. 67. Court order, as hosted by the American Hospital Association, 2024-06-20. aha.org/system/files/media/file/2024/06/opinion-order-in-aha-et-al-v-x
- Technical Marketing. Which software will sign a HIPAA BAA? 28 common tools, checked. Technical Marketing, 2026-11. technicalmarketing.ai/reports/hipaa-baa-availability/ Our own data.
- Federal Trade Commission. FTC Enforcement Action to Bar GoodRx from Sharing Consumers’ Sensitive Health Info for Advertising. Federal Trade Commission, 2023-02-01. ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2023/02/ftc-enforcement-action
- Federal Trade Commission. FTC to Ban BetterHelp from Revealing Consumers’ Data, Including Sensitive Mental Health Information, to Facebook and Others for Targeted Advertising. Federal Trade Commission, 2023-03-02. ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2023/03/ftc-ban-betterhelp-rev
- Federal Trade Commission. Ovulation Tracking App Premom Will be Barred from Sharing Health Data for Advertising Under Proposed FTC Order. Federal Trade Commission, 2023-05-17. ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2023/05/ovulation-tracking-app
- Federal Trade Commission. Proposed FTC Order will Prohibit Telehealth Firm Cerebral from Using or Disclosing Sensitive Data for Advertising Purposes, and Require it to Pay $7 Million. Federal Trade Commission, 2024-04-15. ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/04/proposed-ftc-order-wil
- Federal Trade Commission. Health Breach Notification Rule (89 FR 47028, final rule), 16 CFR 318.1(a). Federal Register (govinfo.gov), 2024-07-29. govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2024-05-30/pdf/2024-10855.pdf
- Federal Trade Commission. FTC Finalizes Changes to the Health Breach Notification Rule. Federal Trade Commission, 2024-04-26. ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/04/ftc-finalizes-changes-
- Washington State Legislature. Chapter 19.373 RCW, Washington My Health My Data Act (RCW 19.373.010(8)). Washington State Legislature, 2023. app.leg.wa.gov/rcw/default.aspx?cite=19.373&full=true
- HHS Office for Civil Rights. Manasa Health Center resolution agreement (HHS HIPAA enforcement page). U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2023-06-05. hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/compliance-enforcement/agreements/mana
- HHS Office for Civil Rights and Manasa Health Center. Resolution Agreement and Corrective Action Plan, Manasa Health Center, LLC (HHS TN 20-380176). U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2023-03-28. hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/compliance-enforcement/agreements/mana
- HHS Office for Civil Rights. Dental Practice Pays $10,000 to Settle Social Media Disclosures of Patients’ Protected Health Information. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2019-10-02. hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/compliance-enforcement/agreements/elit
- HHS Office for Civil Rights and Elite Dental Associates. Resolution Agreement and Corrective Action Plan, Elite Dental Associates (HHS TN 16-240465). U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2016-06-04. hhs.gov/sites/default/files/elite-dental-ra-cap.pdf
- HHS Office for Civil Rights. HHS Civil Rights Office Enters Settlement with Dental Practice Over Disclosures of Patients’ Protected Health Information. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2022-12-14. hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/compliance-enforcement/agreements/new-
- HHS Office for Civil Rights and New Vision Dental. Resolution Agreement and Corrective Action Plan, New Vision Dental (OCR Transaction Number 18-288980). U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2017-11-29. hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/compliance-enforcement/agreements/new-
- HHS Office for Civil Rights. Dr. U. Phillip Igbinadolor, D.M.D. & Associates, P.A. (UPI) HIPAA Enforcement Action. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2022-03-28. hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/compliance-enforcement/agreements/upi/
- Federal Trade Commission. Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (89 FR 68034). Federal Register (govinfo.gov), 2024-10-21. govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2024-08-22/pdf/2024-18519.pdf
- Federal Trade Commission. 16 CFR 465.2 Fake or false consumer reviews, consumer testimonials, or celebrity testimonials. Legal Information Institute (copy of the e-CFR text), 2024-10-21. law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/16/465.2
- Federal Trade Commission. Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials. Federal Trade Commission, 2024-08-14. ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/08/federal-trade-commissi
- Federal Trade Commission. 16 CFR 465.4 Buying positive or negative consumer reviews. Legal Information Institute (copy of the e-CFR text), 2024-10-21. law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/16/465.4
- Federal Trade Commission. 16 CFR 465.7 Review suppression. Legal Information Institute (copy of the e-CFR text), 2024-10-21. law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/16/465.7
- Federal Trade Commission. FTC Warns 10 Companies About Possible Violations of the Agency's New Consumer Review Rule. Federal Trade Commission, 2025-12-22. ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/12/ftc-warns-10-companies
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Annual Civil Monetary Penalties Inflation Adjustment (Federal Register document 2026-01688). Federal Register, 2025 adjustment, published 2026-01-28. public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2026-01688.pdf
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Notification of Enforcement Discretion Regarding HIPAA Civil Money Penalties (84 FR 18151). Federal Register (govinfo.gov), 2019-04-30. govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2019-04-30/pdf/2019-08530.pdf
- AMA Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs. AMA Code of Medical Ethics, Opinion 9.6.1 Advertising & Publicity. American Medical Association, 2026-11-10. code-medical-ethics.ama-assn.org/ethics-opinions/advertising-publicity
- Federal Trade Commission. Health Products Compliance Guidance. Federal Trade Commission, 2022-12. ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/health-products-compliance-guidanc
- Federal Trade Commission. Health Products Compliance Guidance. Federal Trade Commission, 2022-12. ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/Health-Products-Compliance-Guidance.p
- California Legislature. California Business and Professions Code section 651. FindLaw (reproduction of the California Code), 2026-01-01. codes.findlaw.com/ca/business-and-professions-code/bpc-sect-651/
- California Legislature. California Business and Professions Code section 2271. FindLaw (reproduction of the California Code), 2026-01-01. codes.findlaw.com/ca/business-and-professions-code/bpc-sect-2271/
- Texas Medical Board. 22 Tex. Admin. Code section 164.3 - Prohibited Acts or Omissions in Advertising. Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute (reproduction of the Texas Administrative Code), 2025-01-09. law.cornell.edu/regulations/texas/22-Tex-Admin-Code-SS-164-3
- Dr. Shahinaz Soliman, M.D. (CallMyDoc). State of Patient Phone Communication 2026: Data from 29 Million Calls. CallMyDoc (Sphinx Medical Technologies, Inc.), 2025. blog.callmydoc.com/new-blog-1/patient-phone-communication-2026 Secondary source.
- Majed Al-Turbag, Mary Mooney, Margarita Corry. A systematic review and meta-analysis of appointment reminders for enhancing hospital attendance. Journal of Hospital Management and Health Policy, 2026. jhmhp.amegroups.org/article/view/10215/html
- Annapoorna Kini et al.. Conversational artificial intelligence for pre-procedural patient preparation: implementation, validation and patient satisfaction. npj Digital Medicine, 2025. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13710839
- HHS Office for Civil Rights. Business Associates Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs). U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2026. hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance/business-associates/i
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. 45 CFR 164.502 (Code of Federal Regulations, current text as reproduced by Cornell LII). Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (copy of the CFR), 2024. law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/164.502
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. 45 CFR 164.504 (Code of Federal Regulations, current text as reproduced by Cornell LII). Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (copy of the CFR), 2024. law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/164.504
- HHS Office for Civil Rights. Business Associate Contracts: Sample Business Associate Agreement Provisions. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2013. hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/covered-entities/sample-business-assoc
- California Legislature. California Health and Safety Code section 1339.75 (Chapter 2.13, Artificial Intelligence in Health Care Services). California Legislative Information (leginfo.legislature.ca.gov), 2024. leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=HS
- Utah Legislature. Utah Code 13-77-103 Required disclosures. Utah State Legislature (le.utah.gov), 2025-05-07. le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter77/C13-77-S103_2025050720250507.html
- Utah Legislature. Utah Code 13-77-101 Definitions. Utah State Legislature (le.utah.gov), 2026-05-06. le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter77/C13-77-S101_2026050620260506.html
- Texas Legislature. H.B. No. 149 (enrolled), Texas Responsible Artificial Intelligence Governance Act. Texas Legislature Online (capitol.texas.gov), 2026-01-01. capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/89R/billtext/html/HB00149F.htm
- American Medical Association. Augmented Intelligence Development, Deployment, and Use in Health Care (AMA policy). American Medical Association, 2024-11-12. ama-assn.org/system/files/ama-ai-principles.pdf
- Utah Legislature. Utah Code 13-77-104 Safe harbor. Utah State Legislature (le.utah.gov), 2025-05-07. le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter77/C13-77-S104_2025050720250507.html
- Gartner, Inc.. Gartner Survey Finds 64% of Customers Would Prefer That Companies Didn't Use AI For Customer Service. Gartner, Inc., 2023-12. gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2024-07-09-gartner-survey-finds
- Lingli Wang, Ni Huang, Yili Hong, Luning Liu, Xunhua Guo, Guoqing Chen. Voice-based AI in call center customer service: A natural field experiment. Production and Operations Management (Wiley), via Crossref, 2023. doi.org/10.1111/poms.13953
- Relatient. Relatient Voice AI Deflects More Than 60% of Routine Appointment Scheduling Calls. Relatient (via Business Wire), 2025. relatient.com/resources/press-release/relatient-voice-ai-deflects-more Secondary source.
- United States Congress. 18 U.S.C. 2511: Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (US Code text), 2026. law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2511
- Federal Communications Commission. Implications of Artificial Intelligence Technologies on Protecting Consumers from Unwanted Robocalls and Robotexts, Declaratory Ruling, FCC 24-17. Federal Communications Commission, 2024-02-08. docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-24-17A1.pdf
- United States Congress. 47 U.S.C. 227: Restrictions on use of telephone equipment. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (US Code text), 2026. law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/47/227
- Christopher C. Rivers, Tribunal Member, Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia). Moffatt v. Air Canada, 2024 BCCRT 149. Civil Resolution Tribunal of British Columbia, 2024-02-14. decisions.civilresolutionbc.ca/crt/crtd/en/525448/1/document.do
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Table 4. Employer Costs for Employee Compensation for private industry workers by occupational and industry group [June 2026]. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026-06. bls.gov/news.release/ecec.t04.htm
- Brynjolfsson, Li, and Raymond. Generative AI at Work. National Bureau of Economic Research, 2023. doi.org/10.3386/w31161
- Erik Brynjolfsson, Danielle Li, Lindsey R. Raymond. Generative AI at Work. National Bureau of Economic Research (Working Paper 31161), 2023. nber.org/papers/w31161
- Noy and Zhang. Experimental evidence on the productivity effects of generative artificial intelligence. Science, 2023. doi.org/10.1126/science.adh2586
- Dell'Acqua et al.. Navigating the Jagged Technological Frontier: Field Experimental Evidence of the Effects of AI on Knowledge Worker Productivity and Quality. Harvard Business School, 2023. mitsloan.mit.edu/sites/default/files/2023-10/SSRN-id4573321.pdf
- Anders Humlum, Emilie Vestergaard. Large Language Models, Small Labor Market Effects (BFI Working Paper 2025-56). Becker Friedman Institute, University of Chicago, 2025-04. bfi.uchicago.edu/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/BFI_WP_2025-56-3.pdf
- Anders Humlum, Emilie Vestergaard. Still Waters, Rapid Currents: Early Labor Market Transformation under Generative AI (NBER Working Paper 33777; previously 'Large Language Models, Small Labor Market Effects'). National Bureau of Economic Research, 2026-03. nber.org/papers/w33777
- arXiv:2605.14830. Agentic AI and Human-in-the-Loop Interventions: Field Experimental Evidence from Alibaba's Customer Service Operations. arXiv (preprint), 2026-05. arxiv.org/abs/2605.14830
- American Medical Association, Center for Digital Health and AI. 2026 Physician Survey on Augmented Intelligence. American Medical Association, 2026. ama-assn.org/system/files/physician-ai-sentiment-report.pdf
- American Medical Association. More than 80% of physicians use AI professionally: AMA survey. American Medical Association (AMA News Wire), 2026. ama-assn.org/practice-management/digital-health/more-80-physicians-use
- MGMA. Automatic for the people: AI for front office access. Medical Group Management Association, 2026. mgma.com/mgma-stat/automatic-for-the-people-ai-for-front-office-access
- MGMA. Sizing up the market for AI chatbots and virtual assistants in medical practices in 2025. Medical Group Management Association (MGMA Stat), 2025-04-08. mgma.com/mgma-stat/sizing-up-the-market-for-ai-chatbots-virtual-assist
- Erik Brynjolfsson, Daniel Rock, Chad Syverson. The Productivity J-Curve: How Intangibles Complement General Purpose Technologies. National Bureau of Economic Research (Working Paper 25148), 2018-10. nber.org/papers/w25148
- HHS Office for Civil Rights. HIPAA Security Rule To Strengthen the Cybersecurity of Electronic Protected Health Information (notice of proposed rulemaking, 90 FR 898). Federal Register (govinfo.gov), 2025-01-06. govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2025-01-06/pdf/2024-30983.pdf
- HHS Office for Civil Rights. HHS/OCR RIN 0945-AA22: HIPAA Security Rule to Strengthen the Cybersecurity of Electronic Protected Health Information (Unified Agenda entry). Reginfo.gov (OIRA / GSA), 2026-11-10. reginfo.gov/public/do/eAgendaViewRule?pubId=202510&RIN=0945-AA22
- CBS News (MoneyWatch). Eating disorder helpline shuts down AI chatbot that gave bad advice. CBS News, 2023-05. cbsnews.com/news/eating-disorder-helpline-chatbot-disabled Secondary source.
- National Institute of Standards and Technology. Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework: Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile, NIST AI 600-1. National Institute of Standards and Technology, 2024-07. nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ai/NIST.AI.600-1.pdf
- Alec Tyson, Giancarlo Pasquini, Alison Spencer and Cary Funk. 60% of Americans Would Be Uncomfortable With Provider Relying on AI in Their Own Health Care. Pew Research Center, 2022-12. pewresearch.org/science/2023/02/22/60-of-americans-would-be-uncomforta
- Talker Research (commissioned by PatientPoint). Is your doctor stuck in 2011? (survey of 2,000 US adults on doctor visits). Talker Research, 2025-07. talkerresearch.com/dr-past-patients-say-doctor-visits-feel-outdated/ Secondary source.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Chatbots in consumer finance. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, 2023-06-06. consumerfinance.gov/data-research/research-reports/chatbots-in-consume
- Randall A. Lewis; Justin M. Rao. The Unfavorable Economics of Measuring the Returns to Advertising. The Quarterly Journal of Economics (Oxford University Press), 2015. doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjv023
- Brett R. Gordon; Florian Zettelmeyer; Neha Bhargava; Dan Chapsky. A Comparison of Approaches to Advertising Measurement: Evidence from Big Field Experiments at Facebook. Marketing Science (INFORMS), 2019. doi.org/10.1287/mksc.2018.1135
- Thomas Blake; Chris Nosko; Steven Tadelis. Consumer Heterogeneity and Paid Search Effectiveness: A Large-Scale Field Experiment. Econometrica (Econometric Society), 2014. doi.org/10.3982/ECTA12423
- Ron Berman. Beyond the Last Touch: Attribution in Online Advertising. Marketing Science (INFORMS), 2018. doi.org/10.1287/mksc.2018.1104
- SmartCompany. Are you letting online leads go cold? (quoting Oldroyd, McElheran and Elkington, The Short Life of Online Sales Leads, Harvard Business Review, March 2011). SmartCompany (Australia), 2011. smartcompany.com.au/marketing/20110704-are-you-letting-online-leads-go Secondary source.
- Sunil Gupta; Donald R. Lehmann; Jennifer Ames Stuart. Valuing Customers. Journal of Marketing Research (American Marketing Association), 2004. doi.org/10.1509/jmkr.41.1.7.25084
- Frederick F. Reichheld; W. Earl Sasser, Jr.. Zero Defections: Quality Comes to Services. Harvard Business Review (excerpt hosted by Bain & Company), 1990. bain.com/insights/zero-defections-quality-comes-to-services-harvard-bu Secondary source.
Cite this paper
Mike Golliet. "Medical practice marketing: what the evidence and the rules say." Technical Marketing, November 10, 2026. https://technicalmarketing.ai/papers/medical-practice-marketing/
You may quote from this paper with a link to this page. It describes rules and research in general terms and is not legal, medical, tax or financial advice. Found an error? Tell us and we will correct it and note the change here.