technicalmarketing.ai Free AI audit

Report

How does BrightEdge's AI search research compare with local AI answers?

BrightEdge† (SEO platform) tracks AI Overviews and reports them on about 48% of tracked queries in February 20261. We asked ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity 199 local questions, a much smaller, local-only set2. Both show engines citing different sources: BrightEdge† reports that about 17% of its AI Overview citations ranked in the organic top ten1, and 88% of our cited websites came from one assistant2.

What did BrightEdge and we each measure?

BrightEdge† draws its figures from keyword sets and prompt sets that it tracks in its own tools, the Generative Parser and AI Catalyst. For most studies it does not state how many keywords were tracked3,4. Our figures come from two small studies of our own. Table 1 puts the two side by side, and the paragraph after it describes ours.

Table 1. What each study measured

BrightEdge†Ours
SampleTracked keywords; 2,580 finance and 2,760 healthcare in one study, other counts not stated3,5199 local questions, 597 answers2; 63 questions asked five times, 945 answers6
DatesMay 2024 to December 2025 in one study, February 2025 to February 2026 in another1,5November 10 and 11, 20262,6
MarketCountry not stated for the AI Overviews studies; United States for the AI Mode study1,716 US cities, 23 kinds of business2
Kind of questionKeywords in nine verticals, healthcare, finance and restaurants among them1"Who is a good dentist in Atlanta, GA?" with the city and business changed2
EnginesGoogle AI Overviews; ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and AI Mode in a five-engine study8ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity2
MethodDaily tracking of presence and weekly analysis of citation overlap1API calls with web search on, each question asked once2

In our first study we recorded the businesses each assistant named and the websites it cited. Names were matched across assistants by spelling, and the answers describe those models on that day2. Our repeat study asked 63 of the questions five times each, about dentists, primary care doctors, family law attorneys and accountants, and collected the five answers within about 20 minutes6.

The difference in scale is plain. BrightEdge† does not state the size of most of its sets, so we cannot line the two up by count. Ours is small: 597 answers in the first study and 945 in the repeat.

Where do BrightEdge and our data agree?

Engines cite different sources. BrightEdge† reports that about 17% of the sources cited in AI Overviews also ranked in the organic top ten, a figure that stayed flat from February to July 20251. A later nine-industry study reports 16.7%, and says the share of citations ranking anywhere in organic results was 54.5%9. In its five-engine study, BrightEdge† reports the overlap in cited sources between pairs of engines at 16% to 59%8. In our study, 88% of the websites cited were cited by only one of the three assistants2. The units differ. BrightEdge† compares citations with Google's organic rankings and engine with engine, and we compare three assistants with each other without looking at Google's rankings. The shared direction is that no single list of sources serves every engine.

Engines name different brands. BrightEdge† reports that ChatGPT and Gemini shared only about 2 of their top 5 brands in any given category10, and that pairwise overlap in named brands across five engines fell between 36% and 55%8. In our study, any two assistants overlapped on between 11.9% and 14.3% of the businesses they named, and 4.1% of the businesses were named by all three2. The two are not one measure. BrightEdge† looks at the top brands per category across B2B and consumer topics, and our figure covers every business named for one question about one city, so the percentages should not be read against each other.

Answers move. BrightEdge† reports average citation volatility in finance of 65% for ChatGPT, 75% for AI Mode and 95% for AI Overviews, defined as average percentage changes across citation sources, over a period it does not state11. A weekly teaser from BrightEdge† says Reddit's citation presence in ChatGPT fell from 17.2% to zero across two weeks in August 202612. In our repeat study, a business named in one answer was in another answer to the same question from the same assistant 55% of the time6. Two answers from the same assistant shared 43.2% of the businesses either named6. Both show change, but over different spans. BrightEdge† measures sources over weeks in finance, and we measure businesses within about 20 minutes on one day.

Where do they differ, and why?

User-generated content and Reddit. BrightEdge† reports that about 17.5% of AI Overviews citations came from user-generated content platforms, against 0.5% for ChatGPT and 0.2% for Gemini8. In our study Gemini cited Reddit in 42% of its answers, ChatGPT in 2% and Perplexity in 0%2. Three reasons apply. BrightEdge† counts the share of citations that come from a class of platforms, and we count the share of answers that cite one site. Its prompts span industries such as finance, healthcare, restaurants and travel, with the prompt count, country and dates not stated8, and ours are local questions put on one day. Dates also matter for Reddit specifically, because BrightEdge† reports a collapse in Reddit's presence in ChatGPT within two weeks12. A Reddit figure from one date is a figure for that date.

Local queries. BrightEdge† reports that local and provider-intent healthcare queries, such as a dermatologist near me, had AI Overviews on 100% of tracked keywords in December 2023, 14% in December 2024 and 0% in December 2025, and reads this as Maps, the local pack and organic listings handling those searches3. Our data cannot confirm or add to that figure. We asked assistants for named businesses, and the three assistants named 2,975 of them2. BrightEdge† measures whether Google's results page shows an AI Overview for a query, and we measure what an assistant answers when asked. Those are different products and different questions.

Differences by industry and by trade. BrightEdge† reports that top-ten organic overlap of AI Overview citations ranged from 24% in healthcare to 11% in finance1, and that 76% of restaurant citations came from sources outside the organic top 1001. In our study the share of businesses that all three assistants named was 1.1% for dentists, 0% for accountants and 6.9% for roofers2. For electricians, asked about in three cities only, it was 29%, a small sample2. Across the 16 cities the share ranged from 1.9% in Charlotte to 7.9% in Seattle2. The splits answer different questions: BrightEdge†'s compares citations with Google's rankings, ours compares assistants with each other. BrightEdge† lists nine verticals, with no legal or home-services category1, and ours include trades, legal, accounting and health.

What did each study measure that the other did not?

BrightEdge† measured how often Google shows an AI Overview at all. It reports presence rising from roughly 30% to 48% of tracked queries over the year to February 2026, with about 52% showing none1. It reports that AI Overviews averaged over 1,200 pixels tall when present1, and that healthcare coverage was 88% and finance 21% at the end of 20255. It also reports on Google's two AI surfaces: google.com made up 44.9% of AI Mode citations and 9.9% of AI Overviews citations in August 20267.

It also measured traffic, which gives context for how much weight to put on any of this. BrightEdge† reported AI search at less than 1% of referral traffic from January to August 2025, on a sample including many Fortune 100 brands13. Its September 2026 market pulse reports AI platforms at 2.25% of search activity and Google at 86.3%14. It also reports ChatGPT at 96.3% of AI referral traffic14. A September 2026 BrightEdge† press release says total referral traffic from AI platforms grew roughly 73% in less than a year15. The pulse page notes that BrightEdge† restated its historical data in July 202614.

We measured which local businesses and which websites the assistants named. All three assistants put the same business first in 9 of 199 questions2. The most-cited websites were reddit.com in 87 answers, threebestrated.com in 76 and consumeraffairs.com in 712. The 25 most-cited websites drew 29% of citations and were directories, review platforms, list sites, publishers and a forum, and websites cited in only one city drew 39%2. In the repeat study an assistant named 6.2 businesses in its first answer and 13.5 different businesses across five answers6. Per-business results for local questions do not appear in the BrightEdge† pages we hold.

What does neither study show?

Whether a local business named or cited in an AI answer gets more calls or customers is NF; the nearest evidence is that BrightEdge† says AI search worked as a research channel with near-zero direct conversions tracked, giving no rates and covering large brands13.

BrightEdge†'s AI Overview rates for legal, home-services or accounting queries are NF; the nearest evidence is the healthcare local figure BrightEdge† reports3 and the list of industries it publishes8. Its other local-query figures are NF in our evidence, which says nothing about whether BrightEdge† has published them.

How often Google shows an AI Overview for the local questions we asked is NF; the nearest evidence is our own note that API answers are a baseline and not what every signed-in user sees2. A same-day comparison of an AI Overview and an assistant's answer to one local question is NF as well.

What can a local practice take from both?

We think two points hold up across both sets of data. Answers differ by assistant and by day, so a single screenshot of one assistant's answer says little, and a check is more useful when it repeats the questions your customers ask, in each assistant, on several dates. Referral figures also report AI platforms at a small share of search activity, 2.25% in BrightEdge†'s September 2026 pulse14, so the listings and organic search behind most visits still need care. The directories, review platforms and list sites that our assistants cited most often are also where a business can check that its facts are right2.

Our own view sits beside BrightEdge†'s figures. We know from the work that an assistant draws its picture of a business from what is distributed about it online, and gives more weight to sites with authority. We also believe the picture forms fastest when it is one-sided: a small business described the same way on every listing and review site is quickly known for that, and a large one with mixed accounts is slow to move. Neither BrightEdge† nor we have measured that last point.

Where does our service fit?

Our Visibility plan is $999 a month for one location month to month, plus a $499 one-time onboarding fee, and it includes a monthly AI answer check16. Engineered is $2,999 a month plus a $3,000 setup, $1,400 on a 12-month term, and adds alerts when a listing, a ranking or an AI mention drops16. Managed marketing is $1,800 a month on every term16. No plan promises a ranking or a place in an AI answer.

People also ask

How often do AI Overviews appear in Google?

BrightEdge† says AI Overviews appeared on about 48% of its tracked queries in February 2026, up from roughly 30% a year earlier, and that about 52% still triggered none1. The rate is for BrightEdge's own keyword set, which it does not describe, so it is not a rate for all Google searches.

Do AI Overviews cite pages from the top ten organic results?

BrightEdge† reports that about 17% of sources cited in AI Overviews also ranked in the organic top ten from February to July 20251, and 16.7% in a nine-industry study through September 20259. Citations ranking anywhere in organic results were 54.5%9. These are BrightEdge's tracked keywords, not local searches.

Do ChatGPT and Gemini recommend the same businesses?

In BrightEdge†'s 2026 study the two engines shared only about 2 of their top 5 brands in a given category10. In our local study, any two of ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity overlapped on 11.9% to 14.3% of the businesses they named, and 4.1% were named by all three2. The units differ between the two.

BrightEdge† reported AI search at less than 1% of referral traffic from January to August 2025, on a sample that included many Fortune 100 brands13. Its September 2026 market pulse put AI platforms at 2.25% of search activity, with Google at 86.3%14. Neither figure is for small local businesses.

Which AI platform sends the most referral traffic?

BrightEdge† reports that ChatGPT accounted for 96.3% of AI referral traffic in September 2026, far ahead of Gemini, Perplexity and Claude14. That is a share of AI referrals and not of all web traffic. BrightEdge says it restated its historical data in July 2026, so compare its series with care.

Does Reddit show up in AI answers?

In our local study Gemini cited Reddit in 42% of its answers, ChatGPT in 2% and Perplexity in 0%2. BrightEdge† reports that user-generated content platforms made up about 17.5% of AI Overviews citations and 0.5% of ChatGPT's8, and that Reddit's presence in ChatGPT fell from 17.2% to zero in two weeks in August 202612.

Do AI Overviews appear for local searches?

For one local category, BrightEdge† reports that local and provider-intent healthcare queries had AI Overviews on 0% of tracked keywords in December 2025, down from 100% in December 20233. Its figures for other local queries are NF in our evidence, and we measured assistants' answers, not Google's results page.

How to read this page: † a vendor’s own figure, NF not found, ( ) our arithmetic on cited figures, and a small number points to a source below.

Sources

  1. BrightEdge. AI Overviews at the One-Year Mark: Presence, Size, and What They're Citing. BrightEdge, 2025-02 to 2026-02. brightedge.com/resources/weekly-ai-search-insights/ai-overviews-one-ye Secondary source.
  2. Technical Marketing. Who AI recommends locally: a study of local answers. Technical Marketing, 2026-11. technicalmarketing.ai/reports/ai-local-recommendations/ Our own data.
  3. BrightEdge. Healthcare and AI Overviews (Technical Methodology). BrightEdge, 2023-12 to 2025-12. brightedge.com/resources/weekly-ai-search-insights/healthcare-ai-evolu Secondary source.
  4. BrightEdge. Google's AI Overview Rollout Reveals Clear Intent Hierarchy (Data Collected). BrightEdge, 2024-05 to 2025-09. brightedge.com/resources/weekly-ai-search-insights/googles-ai-overview Secondary source.
  5. BrightEdge. 18 Months of AI Overviews (Technical Methodology). BrightEdge, 2024-05 to 2025-12. brightedge.com/resources/weekly-ai-search-insights/ai-overviews-health Secondary source.
  6. Technical Marketing. Does AI recommend the same businesses twice?. Technical Marketing, 2026-11. technicalmarketing.ai/reports/ai-answer-consistency/ Our own data.
  7. BrightEdge. Google AI Mode Cites Itself 4.5x More Than AI Overviews (What we analyzed). BrightEdge, 2026-01 to 2026-08. brightedge.com/resources/weekly-ai-search-insights/google-ai-mode-cite Secondary source.
  8. BrightEdge. Why AI Engines Cite Different Sources but Recommend the Same Brands (scope). BrightEdge, published 2026-04-24. brightedge.com/resources/weekly-ai-search-insights/ai-search-same-bran Secondary source.
  9. BrightEdge. AI Overview Citations Now 54% from Organic Rankings. BrightEdge, 2024-05 to 2025-09. brightedge.com/resources/weekly-ai-search-insights/rank-overlap-after- Secondary source.
  10. BrightEdge. Same Question, Different Brands: How ChatGPT and Google's Gemini Recommend Different Companies for the Same Query. BrightEdge, 2026 (multi-week window, published 2026-06-11). brightedge.com/resources/weekly-ai-search-insights/chatgpt-vs-gemini-s Secondary source.
  11. BrightEdge. Finance AI Citations: How ChatGPT and Google Define Trust Differently. BrightEdge, not stated. brightedge.com/resources/weekly-ai-search-insights/finance-ai-citation Secondary source.
  12. BrightEdge. Two Weeks After Reddit's ChatGPT Collapse: What Replaced It in Education (index teaser). BrightEdge, 2026-08. brightedge.com/resources/weekly-ai-search-insights Secondary source.
  13. BrightEdge. AI Search Visits Surging in 2025—But Organic Search Remains the Cornerstone of Digital Growth. BrightEdge, 2025-01 to 2025-08. brightedge.com/resources/research-reports/ai-search-visits-in-surging- Secondary source.
  14. BrightEdge. BrightEdge AI Market Pulse. BrightEdge, 2026-09. brightedge.com/brightedge-ai-pulse Secondary source.
  15. BrightEdge. BrightEdge Data: ChatGPT Referral Traffic More Than Doubles in 2026. BrightEdge, to 2026-08. brightedge.com/news/press-releases/brightedge-data-chatgpt-referral-tr Secondary source.
  16. Technical Marketing. Pricing. Technical Marketing, 2026-11. technicalmarketing.ai/pricing/ Our own data.

Find out what AI says about you.

A free 20-minute call. We ask the assistants your customers' questions and show you where you come up today.

No pitch unless you ask for one.