Logged-in pages such as a patient portal, mobile apps a practice offers, and public pages where a visitor books an appointment or uses a symptom checker can reveal patient information, because they collect who the visitor is along with a health reason. HHS says tracking on these pages may have access to PHI1.
What does HHS name as the pages to worry about?
HHS's bulletin sorts pages by whether a visitor logs in. On user-authenticated pages, such as a patient portal or telehealth platform, tracking generally has access to PHI. On unauthenticated pages, tracking on many has no access, but a page that lets a visitor schedule an appointment or use a symptom checker without entering credentials may have access in certain circumstances1. HHS's example is a tool collecting the visitor's email address or a typed or selected reason for seeking care.
Two details catch owners out. A portal login page and a portal registration page need no login to reach, so they count as unauthenticated, yet HHS says that once a visitor enters credentials or registration details there, a tool that collects them has collected PHI.
Page by page, what can a visit give away?
| Page | What it can give away | First step |
|---|---|---|
| Patient portal, telehealth platform | Identity plus appointments, diagnoses and billing | No ad or analytics tag unless the vendor signs a BAA |
| Portal login and registration | Credentials and details typed into the form | No tag that reads form fields |
| Appointment or booking page | Email address, the reason for the visit, the appointment | No ad pixel; any tag needs a BAA |
| Symptom checker | Symptoms typed or selected | Treat like the booking page |
| Contact or callback form | A free-text message that can state a reason | Treat as an appointment request |
| Confirmation or thank-you page | A web address or title naming the service booked | Keep the service out of both |
| Chat widget | Whatever the visitor types | Review the vendor and its BAA first |
A web address with the service name in it travels to every tag on the page, and so do health details in a page title, button label or event name. In our scoping, a form that takes an appointment request runs inside a HIPAA-ready program2.
What did the 2024 court ruling leave in place?
Pages about conditions and providers are the contested ground. On June 20, 2024 the court in American Hospital Association v. Becerra declared unlawful what it called the Proscribed Combination in HHS's bulletin of March 18, 2024, an online technology connecting an individual's IP address with a visit to an unauthenticated public page addressing specific health conditions or healthcare providers3. HHS's page says the court vacated the guidance only to that extent1, and the court wrote that its order is not meant to limit other guidance in the same document3. The order did not reach the guidance on portals, booking pages and symptom checkers.
HHS's page also says that connecting an IP address with a visit to a condition page is not enough, by itself, to be PHI when the visit has nothing to do with the person's own care. Its oncology example turns on whether the visitor is seeking care for themselves, which a tag cannot tell.
We are not lawyers. Read the rule yourself or ask your counsel how it applies to you.
Do other laws reach pages that HIPAA does not?
They can. Washington's My Health My Data Act defines consumer health data as personal information linked or reasonably linkable to a consumer that identifies the consumer's past, present or future physical or mental health status4, and it excludes information that meets the definition of PHI4. An FTC complaint against a telehealth company alleged that tracking tools gave sensitive information on nearly 3.2 million consumers to third parties5.
People also ask
Which analytics tools can a healthcare website use?
Any tool on pages that carry no patient information. On the pages above, only a tool whose vendor signs a BAA and is set up to keep health details out of its reports. Google Analytics and the Meta Pixel offer no BAA, and CallRail signs one with its Healthcare Plan.
What should I do about ad pixels like the Meta Pixel on a clinic site?
Keep them off portals, logged-in pages and appointment pages. Meta's terms bar sending health information and mention no BAA. Ad tags on a page where patients type health details can pass that information to the vendor, and HHS says such a vendor needs a BAA.
How often should I re-check the tags on my website?
Whenever the site changes: a new form, chat widget, booking tool or tag. The Security Rule asks regulated entities to assess the need for a new evaluation when their environment changes. Letting an agency add tags without a vendor and BAA review is a common pitfall.
Is a contact form on a clinic website a risk?
It can be. HHS's example of a page collecting an email address or a typed reason for care is exactly what a contact form becomes when visitors describe symptoms in it. In our scoping, any form that takes an appointment request runs inside a HIPAA-ready program2.
Does a cookie banner make tracking on a clinic site allowed?
No. HHS says banners that ask visitors to accept or reject tracking technologies such as cookies do not constitute a valid HIPAA authorization1. A banner does not answer whether the page may send PHI to a vendor at all.
Sources
- HHS Office for Civil Rights. Use of Online Tracking Technologies by HIPAA Covered Entities and Business Associates. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2024-06-26. hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance/hipaa-online-tracking
- Technical Marketing. HIPAA-ready programs. Technical Marketing, 2026-11. technicalmarketing.ai/hipaa/ Our own data.
- United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas. American Hospital Association v. Becerra, No. 4:23-cv-01110-P (N.D. Tex.), Opinion and Order, ECF No. 67. Court order, as hosted by the American Hospital Association, 2024-06-20. aha.org/system/files/media/file/2024/06/opinion-order-in-aha-et-al-v-x
- Washington State Legislature. Chapter 19.373 RCW, Washington My Health My Data Act (RCW 19.373.010(8)). Washington State Legislature, 2023. app.leg.wa.gov/rcw/default.aspx?cite=19.373&full=true
- Federal Trade Commission. Proposed FTC Order will Prohibit Telehealth Firm Cerebral from Using or Disclosing Sensitive Data for Advertising Purposes, and Require it to Pay $7 Million. Federal Trade Commission, 2024-04-15. ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/04/proposed-ftc-order-wil